(10-28-2021, 10:20 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(10-28-2021, 10:00 AM)Squid Wrote:(10-28-2021, 07:35 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(10-27-2021, 09:15 PM)Squid Wrote: It matters when health services are too scared to use the word "women" so use confusing language like "people with cervixes" when 50% of women don't actually know what a cervix is. Note that Prostate cancer charities still use the world "men"
You're not referring to the tweet that was aimed at people who have a cervix but aren't on the register for regular screening so need to actively be encouraged by external sources to get a smear test, are you? I'll let you guess the composition of those who have cervix and aren't on the register for smear tests. Hint: trans men over the age of 25 in this country usually have cervixes as hysterectomies weren't offered on the NHS until recently for transition, but they are taken off the register by the NHS to be contacted for smear tests.
"People with cervixes" has been used far more widely than one tweet.
The Lancet saw fit to use the even more dehumanising "Bodies with vaginas" on their front cover recently. Apparently this was them being "inclusive".
That one tweet was what was caught up by a sitting MP, in turn missing the point of the tweet and diverting a drive for people not asked to get cervical screening automatically to get smear tested into a social wedge issue. And that MP instead of admitting their misinterpretation has doubled down and made a mountain out of a flat bit of land. You say it's one tweet, but it's a pretty big "one tweet" though it is an example of why social media, and Twitter especially", is shit.
As for the Lancet article, are you referring to this passage in this article?
"Historically, the anatomy and physiology of bodies with vaginas have been neglected—for example, the paucity in understanding of endometriosis and the way women's pain has been seen as more likely to have an emotional or psychological cause, a hangover from centuries of theorising about hysteria. This exhibition and the Vagina Museum as a whole aim to redress this lack of attention."
Did you read the article? It's an article on the stigmatisation women get for their own biology, the reference to "bodies with vaginas" is literally made in the same passage as the word women. It clearly isn't erasing or altering the terminology of the words women or woman, it wasn't chosen for inclusivity purposes as otherwise it wouldn't use the word women. It was using it in a medical context.
I highly suggest you read the article you're complaining about, it's pretty second wave feminist and I'd imagine you'd like it and agree with it.
And I agree that the NHS should move into the 21st century and be inclusive for trans people so it's less messy for people to use. I'm glad we're on the same page. Then maybe a lot of the fluff and misinformation being used as wedge issues will go away. Same with domestic violence shelters, I'm sure if they were actually properly funded so there's less competition for resources enabling better allocation of said resources for various factors then people would stop complaining.
I read the article. It is dehumanising language, when the word women is perfectly sufficent.
I am not a "body with a vagina" ever.
It is immensely patronising, yet hugely unsurprising that you first accuse me of not reading and then tell me I shouldn't be upset.

