10-02-2021, 09:20 PM
(10-02-2021, 08:41 PM)74bus Wrote:(10-02-2021, 07:53 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I can't argue with that, Derek. What you say makes sense. Silwood's remark was clearly offensive, the jail sentence warranted, but IMO, that wasn't the issue. The broader argument concerns the power of the state to determine what is offensive. The instance I quoted by way of example was where a member of the trans community was allegedly offended by Women's Movement supporters demanding women's only jails. Then the are the other arguments about athletes and gender. The Labour Party was this week splitting into factions over such matters. The world is shrinking and it's disparate communities are colliding, the only way to make sense of the unfamiliar is surely to listen?
During World War Two, Ghandi was listening to a chap on Speakers Corner denouncing the war and the politicians who'd brought it about, whilst a couple of policemen looked on, unperturbed. He said, in admiration, that this was probably only the country in the world that this could take place.
Nowadays, we have the situation where certain universities will only allow inside speakers with whom they agree. Anyone with a vaguely right wing agenda (and I speak as a lifelong socialist), will not be allowed to put forward their views.
JK Rowling only has to comment upon aspects of the transgender debate and she receives death threats.
We need to be careful.
Re. WW2..
I think that Hitler chap was an absolute cunt.

