10-02-2021, 06:46 PM
74bus Wrote:Squid Wrote:Not on this dump mate, where 'you're a cunt' is regarded as the epitome of reasoned debate. It should be clear to anyone that SOTV wasn't in any way supporting the actions of the odious Silwood.Derek Hardballs Wrote:Squid Wrote:Derek Hardballs Wrote:Singling someone out for the colour of their skin, their disability or sexual orientation as long as it doesn’t incite violence whilst hiding behind freedom of speech defence is not acceptable in a civilised society. Why anyone would go out of their way to challenge this point of view is puzzling. At some point the right to offend does have consequences where that line is drawn has to be written into law otherwise you end up condoning without recourse bullying, harassment and abuse.
But at what point should it draw legal consequences? Look at the case of the Nottingham airport tweets, or the Harry Miller case in which the high court ruled police actions had a "chilling effect on freedom of speech". It should be possible to discuss this without the floods of invective SOTV has faced. You might say those cases don't involve racism, but the concept of what it is offensive has spread very widely and police advice often isn't very helpful:
https://youtu.be/f4JYHEzb0S8
I don’t know those cases but my opinion has been consistent throughout the thread. There has to be a line where the law steps in otherwise you will empower people to glibly use racist, homophobic and derogatory terms for the disabled. The government and those within the law set what boundaries they are. If don’t have that deterrent then it’s a free for all and some will not be in a position to argue back and the question should be why they should have to. I do see the dangers of shutting down debate around religion, culture etc but that is not the same as using offensive terms that are solely about someone’s race, ability and sexuality.
I am all for the right to offend and be offended with regards to choices people make. I think Brexit is an awful idea for example and may have said so on occasion. That is criticising a choice. There is a difference. Whether the law has the balance right is open to debate but I’d rather defend those on the receiving end of mindless racism, homophobia etc than those who went out their way to offend.
Which is what SOTV was trying to do, but has instead received a ton of insulting invective in response. It should be possible to debate and discuss these matters.
My perspective is that I am strongly in favour of prison reform and generally oppose custodial sentences for non-violent crime, so I feel torn here. I'm pleased to see a court take a strong stance, but I don't usually favour such punishments.
I do also think the line at which offensive speech becomes criminal speech is quite blurred and we should question what powers we are giving authorities. It's fine to say, "Well it's to fight racism, disablism and homophobia", but those powers may be stretched to broader and unforseen purposes. Again, it should be possible to discuss this.
He was asking whether the sentence was disproportionate and questioning the long term effect that such actions might have in the future, regarding people's right to speak out without being silenced by the powers that be.
Derek H and one or two others have put forward valid arguments that in this case, the threat to civil liberties was outweighed by the nature of the crime, but most of the posts aren't worth bothering with.
Good post 74Bus. It's clear to see we all agree the guy is a moron and good to hear the different viewpoints around that reasoning. I don't think the abuse is warranted and I've always been suspicious of the motive for it. As said back up the thread, there is currently a massive difference in opinion between the Women's Movement and the trans community. It is a regular argument on Radio 4 and it is somehow always the same side which finds the need to get abusive. Discussion of sensitive matters is a necessity.


. That is criticising a choice. There is a difference.