03-08-2019, 11:54 AM
(03-08-2019, 11:14 AM)Statto Wrote: I agree that VAR will creep ever deeper, changing the sport, increasing the tension for TV viewers and advertising potential for broadcasters. A few drinks and "the day" are important, but that moment of exhilaration when the ball hits the net is the drug inside the ground. It will ruin it for stadium spectators by killing that, but the broadcasters don't care as long as they make their bucks. They promised a 'whole new ball game' and are delivering that.
With VAR, Leeds first goal would rightly have been disallowed for the offside player running across the flight of the ball in front of SJ. That incredible atmosphere and what Leeds fans are regarding as a truly special night may have been stopped in its tracks. Imagine Livermore's goal being correctly disallowed against Spurs because he was offside.
Regarding the United decision, it was a nailed on penalty for me. The argument that the incident should only be reviewed in real time is ridiculous IMHO. The slo-mo and stills are revealing. The defender sees the shot coming and puts his arm out first, before the ball is struck. He's anticipating the shot, puts his arm out, then jumps and turns as the shot has been hit. Even though he may have been protecting himself, but he knew what he was doing, making it deliberate.
His reaction was telling. Head in hands. Didn't look like a victim of gross injustice, but someone who knew he had been caught out.
Incorrect decisions are part and parcel and should be left alone, but money talks. The stakes are too high. The reality is that we'll just end up arguing about inconsistencies in VAR interpretation instead, as proved by this thread.
If he knew what he was doing and it was deliberate, why would he deliberately put his arm onto a shot that was heading for the planet Jupiter? He'd have to be a complete nutter to give the ref a decision to make, when no one really knows which way any particular ref is going to go.
On VAR I agree with every word you've said. It'll kill that moment of euphoria that for me has been the thing that keeps me going back, that most ridiculous high that you get when an important goal goes flying in.
For the neutral TV viewer who isn't as emotionally attached, VAR adds to the tension and the excitement, but on the pitch and in the stands, it will kill that instant celebration when the ball hits the net.
It's aimed at the millions of TV glory hunting big team fans, and will be used as such. It won't be any use to the likes of me and thee. As I've said before, when Atkinson's reffing our matches, I won't be able to celebrate a goal fully til I get home.

