03-08-2019, 08:25 AM
(03-07-2019, 10:26 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:(03-07-2019, 10:20 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Clear and obvious error? Nope.
Put simply - had it not been given no one would have commented on it being hand ball.
How long before clever players, when close up to a defender, deliberately flick the ball up to hit an arm and then draw a square with their fingers?
There is the game changing option to use var isn't there?
I know what you are saying but if players knows the ref will give them the benefit of the doubt then clever plsyers will always jump with arms out and have that option for blocking that way 'accidentally'. The player has to have his arms out of the way or he could be doing it deliberately - how would the ref know.
It only became “game changing” when var got involved. The shot that hit the back of his elbow was destined for the stands.
I accept that some players deliberately make themselves bigger when attempting to block shots and the ref should award penalties when arms/hands are in an unnatural position. This is the grey area, I didn’t think his arms were in an unnatural position.
What you seem to be saying is that players are no longer able to charge a shot down etc. They can only stand, run and jump with their arms strictly by their sides?
It’s like the “contact in the box therefore entitle to go down” argument. The ball will sometimes unintentionally hit and arm that doesn’t make it a penalty. There has to be a certain degree of context and interpretation, VAR doesn’t give that it just gives factual evidence of did it hit the arm or not.
No one involved with that game would have complained about a penalty not being given. And certainly not before var.
it’s changing the game and not for the better. Had the shot come from a throw in awarded the wrong way then how long before there’s a demand for it to be taken back to that decision? This search for the “right decision” is a fools gold. It can only exist if every decision from the kick off is reviewed along with every tackle made.

