03-07-2019, 08:25 AM
(03-07-2019, 07:23 AM)steviedm Wrote:(03-06-2019, 10:48 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: 100% for me.
It's been a long standing discussion between me and my old man.
If a player goes round a defender who makes an honest attempt to tackle but takes the man it's a foul, if its deliberate, booking, stops a goal scoring chance, sending off.
Same should apply to handball.
Honest attempt at a block, but hits a arm that stop the ball travelling it's natural path, foul. Deliberate handball, booking. Stops a goalscoring opportunity, red.
I disagree entirely. I concede that if you look at a replay slowed down to about 20%, it looks as if the ball hits an arm that has been slightly moved away from the body. But look at it in real time. Someone has a wild shot that is certainly not heading for the back of the net - so wild it inadvertently hits a defender who barely has time to register what's happening. There's no attempt to cheat, to seek an advantage, to stop the ball travelling on its natural path. How many people shouted PENALTY! as soon as it happened? Perhaps a few over optimistic Man Utd fans. Was it clear and obvious? Anything but. VAR yet again is ruining the game (for proper football fans - it's adding to the drama for those who want the sport to be analogous with the light entertainment industry). The PSG manager's comment that there is no logic to awarding that penalty is spot on. There was no foul play, it wasn't deserved. It was just bloody lucky and another example of how VAR will start to give decisions on technicalities that very, very rarely would be given before its introduction.
This +1000000

