(09-08-2021, 09:00 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote: So you’re saying a policy which Brown and Darling did first, having been mocked by the Tories, only for them to then say nothing when Merkel and then the US did exactly the same, was somehow a mistake? I loathe the banks and propping up their arrogant idiocy (see The Big Short) by throwing public money at them made me sick. But if we hadn’t? The real disgrace is that not a single banker in this country went to jail. In the US only one naive idiot got caught on record and went down. Blaming Brown for the state we’re in is like blaming The band on the Titanic for distracting the crew from the oncoming iceberg.
But if we hadn't?
As I've stated on here ad nauseum for over a decade it was perfectly reasonable for the state to underwrite a proportion of individually held private wealth. But not to underwrite the institutions which instead should have been broken up with real competition and caps on market share introduced.
As it is now in the US, the banks are even larger than they were pre-2008. They are not only too big to fail, they are too big to manage and possibly too big to exist. The old phrase was, 'Main Street will never again bail out Wall Street. That's a noble claim, but the evidence suggests that in the UK and the US, and also in the eurozone, where several countries simply still have broken banking systems (Germany, Italy), the taxpayers are still on the hook. Very little has been done, and another day of reckoning is potentially around the corner.
What do we do then?
I did very well out the 2008 response when Brown reimbursed my investments in Kaupthing Edge & Landsbanki. I've ridden the wave of cheap money to accumulate assets since. And therein lies the problem; if you nationalise risk then no one bearing any risk will encourage you to privatise it again. The state literally backs asset accumulation for the already equity rich - the rest of you - renters, equity poor, young - well you lot can fuck off.
Unsustainable on every political and moral level.

