09-06-2021, 09:48 PM
Well this thread has taken an unpleasant turn since I left it a couple of hours ago. No need for the Uncle Tom stuff.
Just to clarify my comments about Ollie Robinson. I agree he's been the find of the summer. He should probably have been on the Test scene a couple of years ago - but he has seemingly been a bit of a twat in his younger years (sacked by Yorkshire, for instance) and maybe this influenced the establishment against him. Nevertheless, if he's going to stroll in and bowl at 75 mph, he shouldn't expect success at Test level. Application and fitness are essential.
Which brings me on to the England attack. For years Anderson and Broad have decided when they want to bowl. Regardless of age (Anderson) and form (Broad), Root has relied on them totally, sometimes to the detriment of England and other bowlers, who have been denied opportunities. Liam Plunkett, genuinely quick, played just 13 Tests. Steven Finn hasn't been picked since he was 27. Saqib Mahmood overlooked this week despite his sound performances in the makeshift ODI side. Yet the ECB bent over backwards to find time for Jofra, who has rewarded us with very little at Test level. The other day Michael Vaughan pointed out that Chris Woakes' figures as an all-rounder are up there with Botham, Flintoff and Stokes. But how many times over the years has he been fit and available, but omitted to make room for a more fashionable player? And he always has to wait while Jimmy and Stuart (and now Ollie) get the new ball, the choice of ends.
Former New Zealand captain and all-round cricket guru Jeremy Coney has been the only one to put this into words publicly during 2021. Anderson and Broad are very much the elephant in the room. They have been so influential and important, but when does it end? Anderson can no longer play a two innings match, nor can he contribute anything with the bat or much in the field. Broad had a purple patch last year and early this, but the selectors couldn't play him and not Anderson, so we carried two players with limitations (I fully expect us to waste two seats on the plane to Australia on these fellows if the Ashes series happens). Meanwhile potentially useful bowlers come and go. No chance to develop at Test level. I genuinely believe that the potential for Anderson to overtake Warne and maybe even Murali has become a more important factor than picking the best team to win Test matches for England.
Joe Root has the opportunity to think for himself and become a true legend as England captain. Or he can be remembered as a top class batsman who won a lot of Tests as captain because he had the best seam bowling attack around. Move forward without Broad and Anderson, that's my recommendation.
Just to clarify my comments about Ollie Robinson. I agree he's been the find of the summer. He should probably have been on the Test scene a couple of years ago - but he has seemingly been a bit of a twat in his younger years (sacked by Yorkshire, for instance) and maybe this influenced the establishment against him. Nevertheless, if he's going to stroll in and bowl at 75 mph, he shouldn't expect success at Test level. Application and fitness are essential.
Which brings me on to the England attack. For years Anderson and Broad have decided when they want to bowl. Regardless of age (Anderson) and form (Broad), Root has relied on them totally, sometimes to the detriment of England and other bowlers, who have been denied opportunities. Liam Plunkett, genuinely quick, played just 13 Tests. Steven Finn hasn't been picked since he was 27. Saqib Mahmood overlooked this week despite his sound performances in the makeshift ODI side. Yet the ECB bent over backwards to find time for Jofra, who has rewarded us with very little at Test level. The other day Michael Vaughan pointed out that Chris Woakes' figures as an all-rounder are up there with Botham, Flintoff and Stokes. But how many times over the years has he been fit and available, but omitted to make room for a more fashionable player? And he always has to wait while Jimmy and Stuart (and now Ollie) get the new ball, the choice of ends.
Former New Zealand captain and all-round cricket guru Jeremy Coney has been the only one to put this into words publicly during 2021. Anderson and Broad are very much the elephant in the room. They have been so influential and important, but when does it end? Anderson can no longer play a two innings match, nor can he contribute anything with the bat or much in the field. Broad had a purple patch last year and early this, but the selectors couldn't play him and not Anderson, so we carried two players with limitations (I fully expect us to waste two seats on the plane to Australia on these fellows if the Ashes series happens). Meanwhile potentially useful bowlers come and go. No chance to develop at Test level. I genuinely believe that the potential for Anderson to overtake Warne and maybe even Murali has become a more important factor than picking the best team to win Test matches for England.
Joe Root has the opportunity to think for himself and become a true legend as England captain. Or he can be remembered as a top class batsman who won a lot of Tests as captain because he had the best seam bowling attack around. Move forward without Broad and Anderson, that's my recommendation.


