(02-27-2019, 03:24 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:(02-27-2019, 03:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(02-27-2019, 02:27 PM)clem4england Wrote:(02-27-2019, 08:17 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:Exactly how I see it too - some breathtaking football at times but some very basic errors and something missing.(02-26-2019, 11:28 AM)MancBaggie Wrote: There are parallels but (so far) I'd say it is better than that.
If you go back to year Megson, I'd say it is uncannily similar to Mowbray 2006/07. We are still not a sum of our parts.
Aye that’s a fair comparison.
We are not at the level of the Mowbray team of the following season yet IMO. They played better football and as bad as they were at defending it was more from set-plays.
The Pepe Mel time was enjoyable as you had absolutely no idea what was going to happen from minute to minute, let alone game to game, but I’d say this season is more pleasing overall. I thought we were a better team under both Mowbray and RDM compared to this season, we played better football too. I genuinely don’t think we’ve played great football since the change from a back 3... we’ve been more effective away, but overall we look a worse side.
In terms of enjoyment:
Clarke full season
Mowbray promotion
RDM promotion
RDM/Roy season
Roy full season (we finally looked like competing)
This season / Mowbray playoff season
Pulis 9th place season
Clarke/Pepe Mel
AFI/Pulis
Pulis 2nd season
Mowbray relegation
Literally anything, ever
Pulis and Pardew relegation
Not far off those lad - going back to the summer of 05 and given the relative level of opposition:
Clarke full season
RDM/Roy season
Roy full season (some unbelievable aways)
Mowbray promotion
RDM promotion
This season / Mowbray playoff season - so far
Pulis 9th place season
AFI/Pulis
Pulis 2nd season
Clarke/Pepe Mel
Robbohhh's great surrender - hic
Mowbray relegation
Last season
(02-27-2019, 03:21 PM)Dumbo Wrote:(02-27-2019, 03:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(02-27-2019, 02:27 PM)clem4england Wrote:(02-27-2019, 08:17 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Aye that’s a fair comparison.Exactly how I see it too - some breathtaking football at times but some very basic errors and something missing.
We are not at the level of the Mowbray team of the following season yet IMO. They played better football and as bad as they were at defending it was more from set-plays.
The Pepe Mel time was enjoyable as you had absolutely no idea what was going to happen from minute to minute, let alone game to game, but I’d say this season is more pleasing overall. I thought we were a better team under both Mowbray and RDM compared to this season, we played better football too. I genuinely don’t think we’ve played great football since the change from a back 3... we’ve been more effective away, but overall we look a worse side.
In terms of enjoyment:
Clarke full season
Mowbray promotion
RDM promotion
RDM/Roy season
Roy full season (we finally looked like competing)
This season / Mowbray playoff season
Pulis 9th place season
Clarke/Pepe Mel
AFI/Pulis
Pulis 2nd season
Mowbray relegation
Literally anything, ever
Pulis and Pardew relegation
Decent assessment that.
For me personally though, the first season back in the Prem under RDM/Hodgson was the best.
Other than a few shaky months when RDM got sacked and Hodgson came in, that was finally the year we'd stopped Yo-Yo'ing. We also got some massive wins like Liverpool at home, Arsenal away and finally beat the Villa. We finished 11th and finally looked like a 'proper PL team' unlike just the 'once a season wonders' we'd previously looked like in our few visits to the Prem.
Not to mention the arrival of Odemwingie...
Good post - played some great stuff that autumn/ spring
There’s not a lot between those 3-4 years really... Roy’s full season had some brilliant wins, but some of the home games were dire viewing, and I remember him taking a fair bit of flack after the Everton defeat on NYD.
I rate the Mowbray full season highly because I’d started going as an ST holder the year before Megson arrived, and having not really been old enough to appreciate the lows of the 90s, that Robson surrender was my first real shit season, and so Mowbray brought back the fun of football.
I can totally understand why for people who had lived through the darkest days (I was. Junior baggie, so the novelty of football outweighed the gloom) and had seen us when we were actually good, those 2-3 years under RDM/Roy and Clarke would feel so good.

