(02-27-2019, 01:02 PM)Lillwall\s left foot Wrote:(02-27-2019, 12:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote:(02-27-2019, 12:04 PM)Beano Wrote: Not sure about Cornwall in particular, but I think you will find that many areas that relied on seasonal work have
seen huge challenges in opportunity following the arrival of so many Eastern European folks seeking work. That
is good and bad I suppose. Good if you run a business and want to keep costs down whilst increasing unsocial
hours, bad if your a local dependant on such work to avoid being trapped on Welfare.
It is not the fault of the East Europeans, they just want to better themselves but to believe that comes without
consequences for pay and conditions is delusional.
Thanks Beano - a valid point and a benefit to the UK by coming out of the EU. Areas that rely on seasonal workers will employ more of the local workforce during that season and reduce the welfare costs therefore allowing the government to spend more on something else e.g. the NHS.
This will also have a knock on effect of raising wages for the local workforce as well due to less competition. As you say this will mean the costs of that produce will increase but that is understood and a price worth paying (forgive the pun).
See that was easy - any more benefits?
So benefit number one is that seasonal businesses will need to pay more money to less motivated workers, thus increasing the cost of the product and potentially reducing the quality. I'd be all for that if I saw huge queues of local workers held back at the gates and if I expected all our leave voting friends to happily swallow the hyper inflated prices that will follow. "I don't mind paying £5 for a bag of spuds, they were picked by local workers".
But then, a decent wage for a decent job helping the local economy grow, spreading profits and reduce benefits. Who could argue with that.
Fugg, I wish I lived in the polarized world many seem to now inhabit instead of having to look at both sides of the argument in a reasoned way.....it's bloody hard work!
Ps. What happens to the local workforce out of season?
Pps. If your benefits were impacted for the rest of the year because you have declared a few months seasonal work....would you do it?
Never simple is it.........
All very true, and basically as I see it, but I'm still trying to understand the benefits and need the brexiteers to speak up without fear of being shot down immediately. I am genuinely intrigued as to why there is still a thought process that we will benefit from this decision.
(02-27-2019, 01:54 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Well the benefits politically or economically long term are unknown - it would be based on how well the UK managed being out of the EU and would be down to the competence of politicians and civil servants and private businesses etc. Also down to external factors like how other economies are doing and how willing they are to have a trade deal with the UK.
The idea that the UK is leaving a constantly stunningly successful economic unit though should be challenged - the rise of the far right in Europe is tied to continual poor economic performance and the EUs austerity response.
No surprise the vote was for out - it was during yet another downturn when folk were pissed off. Happy folk don't vote for major change. There were also previous bad recessions in the EU prior to this so I don't despair that the UK is not capable of doing a better job long term - I do despair that the UK may not have the right parties to achieve this though and the exit from the EU looks like it will be punishing (if it happens!)
If I read into what you've said there am I right to interpret it as we don't know the future (either way) and we are taking a punt on having the right politicians, civil servants and business decision makers - which you don't think we have in place now.
I don't think that the EU is seen as a stunningly successful economic unit - I don't think that was the argument, the point always was that we are working towards a better future and being part of a large trading block helps us with trade movement and negotiating power throughout the world.
And if the vote would have been in less recessionary times we would have probably stayed in - another thing to thank Cameron for.

