06-29-2021, 09:43 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-29-2021, 09:44 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(06-29-2021, 09:27 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:(06-29-2021, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(06-29-2021, 09:12 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: I fail to understand how a complete accident can be a "stonewall red", so we'll have to leave it there.
Because accidents and intent to win the ball haven't been a factor in whether or not a player deserves a booking for well over 20 years. Any challenge that is dangerous, like that one, will be a red card offence by virtue of there being excessive force regardless of whether it's an accident.
Which part of "we'll have to leave it there" wasn't clear? However;
By extension of your argument, if on the field of play, I'm on one knee tieing a shoelace, and you, chasing a long aerial ball and not looking at the ground, fail to see me, run in to me, fall over and break your arm, that's a stonewall red for me. Which is, of course total bollocks.
I maintain that the Ukrainian ran into the foot full pelt; you could even argue that it was he who was reckless and displaying excessive force.
Oh, and just for clarity, FIFA changed law 12 to "...tackles an opponent in a manner that is careless, reckless or using excessive force..." in 2009, so a bit less than "well over 20 years".
I still therefore retain sympathy for Danielson. Hope that's OK, all about opinions and all that.
You're arguing that something that is dangerous is not a red because it was accidental. That isn't a thing anymore, it hasn't been for bloody ages.
Danielson had his leg so high up in the air studs up that it made contact with a Ukrainian player's knee while he was in mid-air. That is the factor that was dangerous, that was the factor that is covered by excessive force. My point cannot be twisted into the other player running into him as the other player wasn't goose stepping. And unless you're tying your laces while on your back with your feet in the air then no it isn't the same either.
Don't get pissy with my for pointing out the rule to you, if you object to the issue of excessive force take it up with IFAB. That is a red card every day of the week with the rules written as they are, no referee is ever not going to send off a player for that no matter how harsh you feel it is. It's absolutely, 100% a stonewall red card.

