06-18-2021, 12:54 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-18-2021, 01:46 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
The Ismael thread has started a side debate about football styles, which is worthy of further investigation.
Personally I loved the Spain side of 2008-2012, and for me those names will stand out, but for me the best side ever, which was about attacking flair was Brazil 82- how the hell didn't they win that World Cup? It was an almost freak defeat v Italy, and I'm sure if they had won that World Cup they would unquestionably be seen as the superiors of the 70 side, which many hold as the best ever.
However, as a supporter rather than an impartial observer I do question the love of style over grinding out results. Megson is lauded for what he did and some of that football was tough to watch, but 1-0 was often enough, without going past the half way line, much of the time.
On the other hand, Mowbray was like some bohemian poet about football, but ultimately it came up short, despite some memorable days.
I think Atkinson's side is eulogised too much for its attack, but we had a gritty defence too and didn't go hung-ho.
FWIW the pragmatic Hodgson is to me the guy who has given me the best of Albion, a tough side, who could adapt when needs be.
As for direct football, it was appalling what Pulis did. The worst football I've ever seen and I'd say a 1-0 defeat at Southampton in his last days was the most disgusting anti-football event I've witnessed.
So hoof-ball v tippy tippy- as ever, with most things in life, the answer lies in the middle. Give me Roy's 2011 team any day of it all.
Personally I loved the Spain side of 2008-2012, and for me those names will stand out, but for me the best side ever, which was about attacking flair was Brazil 82- how the hell didn't they win that World Cup? It was an almost freak defeat v Italy, and I'm sure if they had won that World Cup they would unquestionably be seen as the superiors of the 70 side, which many hold as the best ever.
However, as a supporter rather than an impartial observer I do question the love of style over grinding out results. Megson is lauded for what he did and some of that football was tough to watch, but 1-0 was often enough, without going past the half way line, much of the time.
On the other hand, Mowbray was like some bohemian poet about football, but ultimately it came up short, despite some memorable days.
I think Atkinson's side is eulogised too much for its attack, but we had a gritty defence too and didn't go hung-ho.
FWIW the pragmatic Hodgson is to me the guy who has given me the best of Albion, a tough side, who could adapt when needs be.
As for direct football, it was appalling what Pulis did. The worst football I've ever seen and I'd say a 1-0 defeat at Southampton in his last days was the most disgusting anti-football event I've witnessed.
So hoof-ball v tippy tippy- as ever, with most things in life, the answer lies in the middle. Give me Roy's 2011 team any day of it all.

