06-08-2021, 09:43 PM
(06-08-2021, 09:24 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:(06-08-2021, 08:52 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Positives:
- he’s won promotion from this division in his first and only full season in it.
- he survived on a shoestring in the PL after getting there.
- he’s a coach, he focuses on fitness and pressing.
- he uses young players and has a track record of developing them.
- his Hudds team used loan players from big clubs, his links to Tuchel and Klopp will help relationships with Chelsea and Liverpool.
- will be happy to work with Dowling - him and Webber were excellent in tandem - it only went wrong when Webber left for Norwich as the financial writing was on the wall at Hudds.
- he’s charismatic and generally well liked by players, Hudds and Schalke got off to very strong starts under him
- he’ll have a knowledge of the Bundesliga, a division that’s still far too untapped by British clubs.
Negatives:
- Wasn’t the first choice, second or third choice.
- Patchy record - massively overachieved at Hudds and started strongly at Schalke but both went south and he looked clueless to stop rot
- Transfer record is patchy - great 2 years at Hudds but fell apart when Webber left with lots of money wasted on young players who didn’t develop as planned
- Football quite attritional at Hudds but can’t deny they massively overachieved
-
Very good summary
When I try and be objective, I don’t think it’s as bad as being made out.
I understand the logic behind the appointment, and I think he’ll do okay. There were better options available on paper, but Wagner has been successful in this division and the PL (something Appy can’t say) and he will be a far better fit and less volatile for our structure than Wilder.

