06-05-2021, 02:32 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-05-2021, 02:37 PM by RonnieWallwork.)
(06-05-2021, 01:25 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I remember when we appointed RDM who only managed one season in League One and didn't achieve anything in that season. He was seen as an exciting appointment at the time. But Appleton would be cheap and show a lack of ambition.
Exactly. Sometimes fans need to look a little deeper.
(06-05-2021, 02:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(06-05-2021, 10:54 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Doesn’t take much for odds to tumble but could be truth in it as he has very good relationships with 2 of the 3 people making the decision at the top.
For all the negativity surrounding Appleton’s potential appointment (yes I’d prefer Wilder or Lampard myself but he’d get my support and I wouldn’t be disappointed) consider this:
40% win rate as a manager isn’t to be sniffed at.
Very experienced in the coaching world.
Highly thought of outside and inside WBA.
Managers/clubs trust him with loan players due to his philosophy.
Answer this:
Is he less experienced or has a worse CV as a manager than any of the following? All were backed. All had a plan. All we’re given the tools to compete at the top end of the championship. It won’t be any different from the clubs point of view. The new guy will have backing.
Megson
Mowbray
RDM
Then add Clarke to that for the Premier league stint.
All were successful. Why do people think Appleton wouldn’t be?
Ok I will give the counter argument just for balance![]()
Megson joined us at an appalling time in our history as a club. The work he did was miraculous and once in a decade perhaps more achievement. I can’t recall who was linked at the time but none would have had much better credentials given how far we had fallen as a club. That is in no way a criticism of him, just simply where we found ourselves in terms of options at the time. I did want him as manager having seen what he had done at Stoke and listened to him being interviewed on local TV you could tell he wasn’t one of the plethora at the time thick as mince football managers on the circuit.
So in summary Megson had a decent CV at both Stockport and Stoke who inexplicably sacked him despite doing a good job. We had zero expectation as a club when he took over with next to no infrastructure to support him. Out of al the examples given he is the best at taking a risk on a unfashionable manager.
Mowbray had by then a decent DoF system to step into and it has to be said very good resources compared to our competitors notably in the promotion season. I can’t recall anyone other than Stoke that season having anywhere near our financial and infrastructure advantage to support them. I would have expected any half decent manager to get us promoted.
The same with RDM who again had a well run club, a decent squad only bettered by Newcastle’s to work with. At that point we were a well oiled and directed football club. It would have been a very poor show if we hadn’t of got promoted.
In summary both Mowbray and RDM slotted into a system as did Bilic to an extent, but ultimately the big advantages we had over our competitors in the Championship were not available to any of them when we got to the Prem and they all struggled or failed to bridge the gap. It’s one thing getting to the Prem it’s another staying their and we have to at some point find a manager who can do both and three managers now have tried to play their way to promotion and Prem safety and been found wanting. The step up to the Prem has proven too big for all of those mentioned on our budgets. The only reason we stayed up when RDM started the season as is because Hodgson became available who hardly fits the mould of Mowbray, RDM or even Bilic.
Your counter argument is very different to the point I’m making.
Mowbray RDM came to a club with huge (in championship terms) £ backing and understanding of what’s required.
The new manager for 21/22 will have exactly the same.
So I ask you..... why not Appleton given his credentials?
(06-05-2021, 02:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(06-05-2021, 10:54 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Doesn’t take much for odds to tumble but could be truth in it as he has very good relationships with 2 of the 3 people making the decision at the top.
For all the negativity surrounding Appleton’s potential appointment (yes I’d prefer Wilder or Lampard myself but he’d get my support and I wouldn’t be disappointed) consider this:
40% win rate as a manager isn’t to be sniffed at.
Very experienced in the coaching world.
Highly thought of outside and inside WBA.
Managers/clubs trust him with loan players due to his philosophy.
Answer this:
Is he less experienced or has a worse CV as a manager than any of the following? All were backed. All had a plan. All we’re given the tools to compete at the top end of the championship. It won’t be any different from the clubs point of view. The new guy will have backing.
Megson
Mowbray
RDM
Then add Clarke to that for the Premier league stint.
All were successful. Why do people think Appleton wouldn’t be?
Ok I will give the counter argument just for balance![]()
Megson joined us at an appalling time in our history as a club. The work he did was miraculous and once in a decade perhaps more achievement. I can’t recall who was linked at the time but none would have had much better credentials given how far we had fallen as a club. That is in no way a criticism of him, just simply where we found ourselves in terms of options at the time. I did want him as manager having seen what he had done at Stoke and listened to him being interviewed on local TV you could tell he wasn’t one of the plethora at the time thick as mince football managers on the circuit.
So in summary Megson had a decent CV at both Stockport and Stoke who inexplicably sacked him despite doing a good job. We had zero expectation as a club when he took over with next to no infrastructure to support him. Out of al the examples given he is the best at taking a risk on a unfashionable manager.
Mowbray had by then a decent DoF system to step into and it has to be said very good resources compared to our competitors notably in the promotion season. I can’t recall anyone other than Stoke that season having anywhere near our financial and infrastructure advantage to support them. I would have expected any half decent manager to get us promoted.
The same with RDM who again had a well run club, a decent squad only bettered by Newcastle’s to work with. At that point we were a well oiled and directed football club. It would have been a very poor show if we hadn’t of got promoted.
In summary both Mowbray and RDM slotted into a system as did Bilic to an extent, but ultimately the big advantages we had over our competitors in the Championship were not available to any of them when we got to the Prem and they all struggled or failed to bridge the gap. It’s one thing getting to the Prem it’s another staying their and we have to at some point find a manager who can do both and three managers now have tried to play their way to promotion and Prem safety and been found wanting. The step up to the Prem has proven too big for all of those mentioned on our budgets. The only reason we stayed up when RDM started the season as is because Hodgson became available who hardly fits the mould of Mowbray, RDM or even Bilic.
I’d also say. Let’s not worry about the Premier league. Let’s get there. We’re WBA nothing more, nothing less. Get there and look at what we have, learn our lessons from this season just gone.


