02-02-2019, 08:27 PM
(02-02-2019, 08:13 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Who is the best judge of chump first team and squads - clearly Norwich and Leeds are the teams to beat this year. I don't trust the judgement of squad strength to someone that dismisses the evidence of their in eyes and results and insists Norwich will be 6th when they were flying high (as they continue to do)
And what is the point of the question - is it a criticism of DM or just wailing? Smith was touted by many but he has done no better than Bruce at Villa after his bounce - but it is a hypothetical that can't be proved either way.
I think the point is that I've seen many moans from people claiming that our squad is weak, others saying "we won't get promoted with this squad" despite the fact that the array of talent we have is clearly far beyond the majority of the league.
League position is not the only indicator of playing squad strength. Man for man Sheffield United have nowhere near the talent of players that we do.
Arguably we've strengthened in the window but we were strong even before. It was refuted when I said that those who couldn't make our bench would get substantial game time at almost any other team in the league; well Burke has walked into Celtic's starting 11 and Sako played for Palace today.
The point is if we're looking at reasons for not going up, DM being dealt a bad hand or us being left with a thin squad are not reasons.

