(05-11-2021, 10:34 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(05-11-2021, 10:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Nothing of the sort - you seem to be using a reference to a 13 year old policy from a completely different Labour cabinet / membership / party, I was just highlighting how you are using any stick to beat the Labour party with. I was offering help in pointing you in the direction of previous Labour governments who will probably have made mistakes that you can reference that are equally relevant. You could even start the point by saying ' this isn't whataboutery'.
Erm, Labour hasn't been in government since 2010 so how else could he answer your question?
So you feel that all previous incarnations of a government should be held responsible for their actions and the current incarnation should make restitution then? Or do you think it was a pointless comment made by someone who has a hard on for anything Labour and negative?
(05-11-2021, 10:57 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:(05-11-2021, 10:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Nothing of the sort - you seem to be using a reference to a 13 year old policy from a completely different Labour cabinet / membership / party, I was just highlighting how you are using any stick to beat the Labour party with. I was offering help in pointing you in the direction of previous Labour governments who will probably have made mistakes that you can reference that are equally relevant. You could even start the point by saying ' this isn't whataboutery'.
It's very simple.
1. I said Labour prevented referrals to foodbanks which could account for some of the foodbank proliferation since 2010
2. You asked for evidence of when that was. Yes, it was in the past. But I am discussing the past, yes?
3. I provided evidence of when that was
4. You resort to sarcasm and your attempted ex post facto attempt at justification embarasses you even further
As being as Labour left office in 2010, when did you think it was going to be when Labour banned referrals? I can't change history, Old Son.
My point at number 1 remains, but there was always likely to be one of those with less acuity who says a valid point is whataboutery, as they often do. Except this time they went for sarcasm that has merely embarrassed them with their pettiness, attempted explanation and how facile a retort it was to attack historical evidence being provided to prove a historical point.
You don't think the Tories could have done anything to rectify the issue in the 11 years in power when it has worsened.
(05-11-2021, 11:28 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Foodbanks are also the sign of the generosity of a civilised society. They're in every major developed economy in growing numbers. I sense that won't be a popular opinion on here, but there you go.
Scraps off the table politics - winnerÂ

