The Covid Arms in Dudley Port
#35
It's clearly a seasonal virus baggy1. They should have dropped all restrictions in summer as I've said a day or 2 ago to build a normal immunity but they didn't and shovelled that lack of immunity into the worst time - winter. There are great papers done on the circulation of respiratory viruses - when the world wasn't such a global place - and remote islands with no contact have outbreaks of viruses that reach them regardless of contact points. Similarly plenty of papers pre-covid showing evidence for lockdowns will only work if ALL contact is removed, complete and total isolation - I think there were some actual research studies done. Hence the advice by all bodies and govts before Covid that lockdown measures should not be used. You just can't do ALL contact removal in this world/time and the virus won't respect a policy of SOME or even ALL removal. It somehow got put in the bin alongside much common sense.

As for the question: "Are you trying to say it would have been no worse if we'd let it run without those restrictions?" We are in Bertrand Russell chocolate teapot/God territory. You ask me if it would have been worse/better and I can ask you the same question but reversed.

But in my mind lockdowns clearly don't work, they've killed an excess of 100K people "with" Covid - i wish we'd report things properly - 40-50 odd thousand of them in the home which I think looks a bit weird and they will continue to kill and disadvantage many others for a decade or more. The total death toll will be significantly higher and total QALYs will be huge. The average age of a Covid "with" death is over 80. The actual QALYs impact will be so much higher in years to come. I was in favour of the Spring lockdown to give us time to work out what it actually was. Was it a really lethal killer or not? It's not. It has a lethality that is greater than many influenza's and some other coronaviruses but let's put it in perspective. That's why the Swede's model worked in the sense of managing a terrible set of short term deaths against the balance of long term consequences. And I simply don't buy the behavioural analysis - blame the people for not doing what they're told - the vast majority have done exactly that.

We have had the worst of both worlds and it's a travesty. A terrible covid death toll and to follow a society, economy, education and people's future health (outside covid) extremely severely impacted by the measures taken the affects of which will be placed on a part of society that will be least able to shoulder the burden: the young, the poor and the vulnerable.

We should not be asking ourselves the question about whether lockdowns work when we consider an approach to a future similar pandemic. That is a question that is simply irrelevant. I don't get the total obsession with it and the labels used lockdown fanatics/deniers/sceptics. It's completely facile. It's the wrong question.

Clearly they don't work because if they did you would use it as a repeatable method for the future. But there is no way you would or could do this again in 5yrs etc.

What we should be asking is why our society in the UK is so fragile that it can't cope with a sharp shock like this. The health of our society, the distribution of wealth, the dependence on the state, the lack of personal responsibility, a lack of sensible govt policy, the conflict of interests of those politicians and scientists in power, a health service that clearly you can't keep shovelling money into, a lack of a balanced economy to generate wealth across sectors, an ageing population, significant population growth, the changing climate (impact on viruses), the affect of social media and other media outlets on our ability to respond sensibly. I'm sure there are plenty more.

There are so many more important questions than asking whether lockdowns work or focussing on a very simple and non-transparent death number. We should be asking these questions now - we should have started asking them in the summer. The trouble is sensible debate has disappeared. Labelling, tagging and slagging, abusing, shutting down, closing free speech. That's what Covid has given us as a byproduct and in many ways that's as troublesome hence my irritated reply to you at the end of my last message. I apologise for that because I fell into the trap too but working with people across the world brings a wider perspective and for those I work with they are horrified at the UK and what's happened and can't understand why we've taken the measures we have.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by Fulham Fallout - 02-16-2021, 11:41 AM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by TETLEY74 - 02-16-2021, 09:19 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by DJPunkRoc - 02-16-2021, 01:01 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by Cuzer - 02-16-2021, 01:39 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by MrFizz - 02-16-2021, 02:42 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by Psalm23 - 02-16-2021, 02:46 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by Peachy - 02-16-2021, 03:01 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by TR 675 - 02-16-2021, 03:02 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by baggy1 - 02-17-2021, 10:27 AM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by woodman - 02-17-2021, 03:03 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by baggy1 - 02-17-2021, 04:17 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by woodman - 02-17-2021, 04:28 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by baggy1 - 02-17-2021, 04:35 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by woodman - 02-17-2021, 06:32 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by baggy1 - 02-17-2021, 07:22 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by baggpuss - 02-16-2021, 08:43 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by Peachy - 02-16-2021, 10:06 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by strawman - 02-17-2021, 07:13 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by woodman - 02-18-2021, 04:19 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by baggy1 - 02-18-2021, 06:20 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by baggy1 - 02-18-2021, 04:33 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by woodman - 02-22-2021, 06:53 PM
RE: The Covid Arms in Dudley Port - by baggy1 - 02-22-2021, 07:41 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: