What has the last twelve months taught us about who we are as a country?
#39
(02-14-2021, 12:46 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-14-2021, 10:35 AM)woodman Wrote: My view is wholesale lockdowns don't work. We can see that from the growing global datasets. The collateral damage will in the long term be more damaging in QALY. A death by covid today is not more valuable than a death tomorrow or lost years in other ways. People die in their thousands and ways will. 
There will be no estimate of the collateral damage and those wanting us locked down forever will sleep easy but if you can't see how poor a tool they are after 12 months then I suggest you do some wider reading. And finally if our reaction to a virus like this is going to be the same every decade when they generally come around then God help us all as it hasn't worked this time and it never will.

Two major points that are vague in the 1st sentence alone - 

1st - Don't work at what? If you are expecting them to stop the virus then you are taking a binary view to one of the most complex issues the world has faced in decades. Lockdowns are a tool in the toolbox, not a wholesale solution. They are to buy us time until we get a vaccine which will also be a tool in the box to use in beating it. Then lets look at the evidence that they do work at reducing transmission. 

Lockdown 1 put in place on 26th March, numbers in hospital peak at 18,974 on the 12th April. Up until that point hospital patients had increased from 1,580 on the 20th March to the 18,974 figure in 23 days. The time from the lockdown to peak in hospital was 17 days. For the unlucky ones that will need hospitalisation we know that the time of getting the virus until needing hospital care is around two weeks. 

Lockdown 2 put in place on 5th November, numbers in hospital peak at 14,490 on the 18th November, it plateaus for a few days and creeps up to 14.506 on the 24th. So again between 13 and 19 days after the lockdown is in place the numbers in hospital start falling.

Lockdown 3 put in place on January 5th, numbers in hospital peak at 33,886 on the 20th January, 15 days after the lockdown is in place and then the numbers in hospital start falling.

So tell me again, how do you think that when the lockdowns are put in place to reduce transmission, and they show that a couple of weeks after implementation the numbers in hospital fall each time, that lockdowns aren't working. They are clearly reducing transmission, which is shown in empirical data above by reducing the sharp end of the infected numbers in hospital.

And 2nd - the only time we have had a 'wholesale lockdown' was in the 1st lockdown, if you genuinely think that we have been in lockdown since then you are mistaken. It has been a restricted lockdown, by far from a wholesale one.

Now onto the rest. QALY - Just to qualify what you are saying here, because I don't want to misinterpret this, you feel that by saving lives at this point it will cause more long term deaths and we should just let covid take its toll and not try to prevent the deaths now. And by the way you are stretching the use of QALY in this matter because it is based on the resource to make choices, where to spend the money most effectively. That isn't an option now due to the emergency that is clearly upon us. 

You are also making a major assumption that both won't occur anyway. We have shown above that without the lockdowns we will have more in hospital for longer, that in turn will lead to more direct covid deaths, that point is pretty definitive now. It will also lead to more non-covid deaths as the health services are going to be focus their dwindling resource on the immediate emergency which means that the long term services that you need will be impacted. 

Your next point - being locked down forever. Who has suggested we will be locked down forever? We have been buying time with these lockdowns until we can get the vaccines delivered, 1stly to those in most need and latterly during this year to the whole adult population. Whilst that is going on trials on children can be carried out safely and decisions can be made on vaccinating them. Being locked down forever is simply scaremongering and not being discussed as far as I can see. There will, no doubt, be longer term implications with travel for instance until the vaccine is rolled out globally, but again that is just a matter of time.

And as for a 'virus every ten years' scaremongering. If nothing else I would hope that the governments of the world have learned how to handle something like this going forward. The country, and indeed the world, was poorly prepared for this event in the ways of resource and funding. Speed of implementation of measures was slow leading to the wider spread. Lessons will have to be learned and mitigation implemented.

Was that debate enough for you? I did notice that you didn't actually have a solution in there, just criticism of the current actions. I ask again, what would you have done differently from September onwards?

Get back to normal... Wink 

Anyway this report is thought provoking...

BMJ article...
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: What has the last twelve months taught us about who we are as a country? - by Derek Hardballs - 02-14-2021, 01:10 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: