01-18-2021, 03:33 PM
(01-18-2021, 03:30 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:(01-18-2021, 03:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(01-18-2021, 03:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I prefer Robinson over Grant. As would most people I reckon.
I feel for Grant, he's been given an impossible job, not suited to his strengths and with a massive price tag hanging over him.
At Hudds he was a goal scorer, often from wide positions, similar in many ways to Wingie, but without the technique, so he hasn't adapted well to being a lone striker up top at all. He doesn't give much outside the box, he isn't lazy mind, just doesn't have anything to offer. He isn't quick, at least not like Robinson, he has a poor first touch, not great in the air and ultimately just not suited to the role he's been signed for.
What Bilic was thinking I don't know.
Sadly this was patently obvious to the Hudds fans who all said as much when we were linked in the summer.
Given how difficult it is to find any semblance of agreement on messageboards, the fact the vast majority of their fans could see it does raise concerns around what our scouting team and Slav saw in him.
I'm sure if/when we go down Grant will be a useful asset in that league, but £16m for a decent Championship striker feels like we've been done.
Really hope he proves me wrong mind!
Scouting team didn't feel he was good value. Bilic was the one who stuck his foot down on this one.
Why I don't think the manager should have a huge say in transfer decisions.
Interesting - I guess Slav must have seen something in his performance in the 4-2 at our place.
He'd been on our radar for a while, but I guess there's a big difference in being comfortable paying £2m for a striker tearing it up in League One when you're trying to add some competition for Rodriguez and Gayle, and paying £16m 18 months later when you need a first choice PL striker!


