12-29-2020, 03:54 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-29-2020, 04:10 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(12-29-2020, 09:54 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(12-28-2020, 08:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Regardless of the spin the up shot of four / five years of Brexit bollocks is no real tangible benefits for most people gained, tangible benefits lost for many people. More red tape costing billions, billions spent ‘preparing’, some nonsense about sovereignty and some angry fisherman! Sunlit uplands indeed.
You will notice next to nothing being any different. As will the vast majority of people.
"Sovereignty" is only nonsense to those who're happy to outsource it. The tangible benefit for us all is that we're off the "ever closer Europe" juggernaut. We've detached ourselves from the protectionist precautionary principles which have defined Europe's (and ours) sclerotic productivity, ballooning welfare budgets and self destructive immigration policies. What we choose to do with this freedom is now entirely in our hands, for good or ill.
Here's another tangible benefit; we're not part of this:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-55464564
Unless you're happy with China's treatment of minorities, sabre rattling with Taiwan, the breaching of the agreement on Hong Kong, extractive imperialism in Africa, hacking of international businesses and governments etc...
Sovereignty is meaningless, we were sovereign in the EU and we are just as sovereign outside of it. That is why it is a nothing statement, we haven't gained it.
7 of the 10 most productive nations on Earth are EU members. The EU is clearly not a barrier to adapting to markets to increase productivity.
Welfare budgets are ballooning all over the developed world owing to demographic problems caused by generational imbalance, on top of the developed world having higher and higher life expectancies. 40% of our welfare budget is spent on the state pension alone. This has nothing to do with the EU.
We were literally the main country that pushed for a closer relationship between the EU and China, we are already part of it. Have you looked at the domestic manufacturing industries? Financial services? Tourism? Universities? I'll also spin this around, were you happy to vote for a party that denied the granting of citizenship to HKers in spite of political pressure from the Lib Dems? Were you happy to vote for a party that ignored the Lib Dems bringing up the mistreatment of minorities in China in Parliament? Were you happy to vote for a party that has only just implemented a watered down version of a Lib Dem manifesto promise? If you gave a shit about China's mistreatment you wouldn't have been a paid member of the Tories. The horse has bolted on China, we did nothing as an EU member to stop this despite being in a position to stop this.
(12-29-2020, 02:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Narrator: The UK didn't stop anything whilst it was in the EU.
Yes we did, the EU Council operates on consensus and through that the UK blocked a lot, not even mentioning the veto. Why do you think the EU were more than happy to offer us a permanent opt out on ever closer union?
(12-29-2020, 03:22 PM)Ossian Wrote: At a bit of a tangent this, but in my view tomorrow's vote should be free and unwhipped right across the house; all parties, no exceptions.
As should all votes, by the way, but that's a separate matter.
It should do but it never will because the political structure in Parliament is fundamentally broken and has been for 150 years and the two main parties thrive on the fundamentally undemocratic nature of the party structure.
(12-28-2020, 10:12 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:(12-28-2020, 07:30 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(12-28-2020, 07:13 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: 7) are you kidding, what are China and India doing today? Over population is the biggest problem.
As of 2019, China and India's per capita emissions are lower than the United States, Canada, Australia and Japan, India's is also below ours and Ireland's. And the biggest problem was how much CO2 the west was pumping out until the late 1990s. I'm not going to blame a single generation for that as it's a collective from generations that have long been dead up to generation Z but it's far too simplistic to pass the buck to the developing world given how much the developed world was responsible and still is responsible. The United States was still responsible for 15% of global CO2 emissions as of 2016 despite only having 4% of the global population.
The point I was making was don’t blame on GB’s baby boomers, China and India are one and 3 in the most polluting countries with India having 14 of the 15 most polluted cities in the world.
The US have always been a massive contributor and that’s not going to change any time soon.
Yes it is an accumulation of generations over time but the Recent acceleration is caused by the over population of our planet. This is the biggest issue that gets ignored.
China and India are not the big issue, as I have just said they have lower per capita emissions than most of the west. On top of high domestic emissions, there's also the issue of developed nations outsourcing emissions to China and India though the supply chains. Regarding population acceleration, this is happening in Africa and undeveloped Asia, not China and India, and it's had a much lesser impact on global emissions than just the top percentile of the developed world.
Germany and Poland are still reliant on coal. The UK has squandered the great platform for renewable and nuclear energy generation that it was given by the coalition government in favour of NIMBYism, allowing coal power plants to misrepresent their carbon emissions and not building nuclear power plants, hell new build houses have no solar power or heat pump regulations for some stupid reason. The biggest issue is a blasé attitude to cutting domestic emissions in the west instead blaming other countries for our problems, hell there's still a desire to build new roads instead of electrifying and expanding the rail network for some stupid reason and people get in a fit over space efficient and energy efficient trams and separated bicycle lanes making it slightly less convenient for them to drive.


