12-09-2020, 01:24 PM
(12-09-2020, 01:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(12-09-2020, 11:53 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(12-09-2020, 09:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(12-08-2020, 02:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well six kids were off ill in one class at my sons school last week. I've know four people who have sadly died and one on a ventilator none of them were in their 80-90's. Let's get back to normal.
Let's base policy on your anecdotes then. Probably better than the ONS's wildly inaccurate figures to be fair.
Just as a matter of interest, these six kids who were "ill" - we're they ill or did they just test postive for Covid. The reason I ask is that in a couple of dozen positive Covid kids' cases I've known around here, not one of them has been "ill".
You'll be posting a graph again soon like the good old days.
The point is as Strawman, Baggy1, myself and others have said you cannot separate the vulnerable from those that less at risk from the disease themselves but can spread it to others. Society, families, caring roles don't work like that. Either you're being deliberately obtuse or your lack of empathy and understanding of how others live is startling.
I notice you didn't answer the question.
I answered it - kids don't tend to get too ill but they are sent home to isolate because they can easily pass it on to others who are at risk.
Ok Proth – here are a few questions for you.
So lets say we go along with your idea of sheltering the most at risk which, of course, includes younger people with chronic illness.
So, assuming the infection rate will increase because no one is taking any precautions in your world, and assuming that if the infection rate increases then there will be more hospitalisations and deaths even among the younger population. Actually it’s not even an assumption, the reality is that if you give an infection more opportunity to spread then cases will increase, so in an environment where many more people will be infected and many without knowing it, then ..
What’s your plan for looking after those who need carers – how are you going to protect them?
How are you going to supply in excess of 12 million people with food, so they don’t have to risk going to the shops?
How are you going to protect those who live with extended families?
What arrangements would you make for those whose children are normally looked after by older relatives after school?
How do you think the ambulance service and NHS will cope with the increased cases? Do we just tell people not to phone 999 when they feel ill enough to require hospital treatment? Noting that even before the pandemic, the ambulance service was not meeting its targets and some people were waiting hours to be treated.
And of course a knock on effect, of their being even more hospital cases and capacity reduction due to infection control, would be that even less people are treated for other illnesses, which is already bad enough.
All of these would, of course, need be achieved by a reduced workforce because of the increased infection spread.

