For so many reasons VAR is not working
#11
I’ve been a backer of VAR from the start, and still do back the concept, but how it’s currently manifesting itself is indefensible.

There is too much money at stake at the top level to accept the level of human error that exists, and there is enough technology available to minimise its impact.

The problem for me is the interpretation of “clear and obvious” error... an “offside” goal being wrongly judged onside due to an armpit is not clear and obvious. The referee giving our pen and missing theirs originally’ the weekend were not clear and obvious.

In reality there’s probably only 1 or 2 clear and obvious errors across all 10 games each weekend, but the fact we seem desperate to make use of the technology is counter productive to its effectiveness.

It’s the same reason I’m against giving captains the right to review. It will just cause more chaos and interrupt the flow of the game, and lead to players feeling they can question the ref’s authority. What we need is a far clearer interpretation of what constitutes clear and obvious.

Give the team in Stockley Park 1 replay, and all 3 members of the team must agree the decision needs review, and only then should the referee on the field be informed.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: For so many reasons VAR is not working - by SW4Baggie - 11-23-2020, 01:23 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: