11-22-2020, 01:25 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-22-2020, 01:40 AM by Dreamkiller.)
(11-22-2020, 01:14 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote:(11-22-2020, 12:22 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote:(11-21-2020, 11:41 PM)Dumbo Wrote:(11-21-2020, 11:35 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: An impartial view on the main talking points.
Albion penalty - The truth? I honestly wouldn't have wanted to call this one. I suspect I could have been watching replays all night and still not really be sure. I'd probably lean towards it not being a penalty, so I'd say the ref was ultimately right to not give it.
United penalty - It's a shit rule. A really shit rule. But as pathetic as the rule is, it's now a penalty.
Penalty re-take - Sorry, but irrespective of the shenanigans of the United player's run up, the keeper can't come off his line. So, as with the other two decisions, the ref's got it right.
If it had happened to Stoke, I'd be gutted and feeling like we'd been done. And you can always summise that if each incident had been reversed, the ref might not have been so keen to make sure his decisions were so spot on. But for me, all the decisions were right.
Sorry!
No Albion pen? Okay, what of the pullback by Maguire in the build up? No pen but a red card for Maguire.
Man U pen? Okay what about the foul on Gallagher in the build up to the United pen? Blatant.
Both decisions were reviewed by BT, and both decisions were in the build up of both penalties.
Thought I'd replied to this earlier, but it seems to have disappeared.
I only saw the MotD highlights Dumbo, so didn't see the incidents leading up to the main points I referred to.
What did the cnuts on MOTD says about the incidents?
Sorry but I can't bring myself to watch them get paid to mutually wank each other off on TV.
On your pen, only Wrighty commented and he was non-commital, just waffled a bit, then they moved onto their penalty which Shearer basically said was a pen albeit he thought the rule was wrong.
All they said about the retaken pen was that they had sympathy with the keeper because of the way the Utd player had farted around on the run up. They didn't actually say 'farted around' though.
That was about it. There was hardly any incisive analysis about any of it. So no change from normal really.
You were last on by the way. Made me feel all nostalgic.

