11-21-2020, 03:08 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-21-2020, 03:13 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(11-21-2020, 02:08 PM)JOK Wrote:(11-21-2020, 12:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:The usual misreading, bending and ignoring then. “The guardian and the Mirror reported” !(11-21-2020, 11:35 AM)JOK Wrote:(11-21-2020, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(11-21-2020, 09:27 AM)Jack Halford Wrote: Fucking hell, most people are sensible enough to follow the guidelines. How many times have we been told it will not be a normal Christmas.
The impact of some of our elderly neighbours not seeing loved ones is huge. Sensible meeting up is what we are on about here.
The problem are those that continue to flout the rules and they are not influenced in the slightest by the “right wing” press.
Public Attitude
Cummings and goings
Here we go again. Same old Same old let’s ignore facts and follow the ‘Left wing’ press line.
The Cummins story broke on the 20th of May. But surveys from April show that this event “undermined people’s confidence”. Wonder where they got their crystal balls. After the event the percentage of people 1200 only questioned who ‘admitted’ not following the guidelines rose from 4% to 9%. hardly mega. And the reason given was the they didn’t agree with them: “There are two explanations for our findings. It could be that people are more willing to discuss their past breaches of the lockdown or that more people have broken the lockdown in the past week.” The second survey linked was of 200 people again not a great cross section and if you read that linked piece, it states : “They then carried out a follow up survey with 200 people on the 27 May to explore the effect of the news.
"Across all 1,201 people interviewed in both surveys, 69 per cent of people reporting they followed government guidance at all times, while 31% reported breaking the guidance to help others, because of a personal need (e.g. work), or because they do not agree with the guidance itself.” Other than suggesting it in the title, where does it conclusively state the Cummins affair altered people’s behaviour?
Here, again, is just a small section of reports from before the 20th of May:
Metro story of crowds in various places ignoring social distancing. 22nd March
Or the thousands that flocked to Durdle Door and Southend in early May.
Treknow on Good Friday.
Crowed London parks reported on the 5th of May.
Crowds on Westminster Bridge on 20th April.
Countless pubs having secret lock-ins.
Or the reports of crowds flocking to markets and shops in London and Leicester on the 3rd of May.
Crowds watching an organised Street Fight in Newcastle. 19th May.
Residents ‘fear for their safety’ as crowds ignore lockdown rules and gather on Sheffield streets. 8th April.
Cops break up crowd for ignoring social distancing rules at vigil for man, 38, who died in motorbike crash. 20th April.
Seaside visitors defy social distancing advice in Hove, Brighton, Skegness… 21st March.
Illegal Rave broken up after 36 hours .
Tens of thousands of people NOT following the guidelines and laws well before the Cummins affair. Do tell me, where did these people get their ‘Cummins excuse’ to ignore the government and scientists BEFORE the actions, you claim caused the opening of the floodgates, triggered by one idiot took place?
The Sun’s headline on the 18th Nov. HO NO, Now UK faces 25 DAYS of Christmas after medic got it wrong.
On the 24th of October the same rag put; HOPES for Brits having a family Christmas have been bolstered as lifting restrictions for two days would only have a "limited impact" on coronavirus spreading, a top expert has said. Quoting professor Neil Fergusson. Adding "It risks transmission and there will be consequences of that. Some people will die because of getting infected on that day."
Not quite the “hailing Christmas is back on / saved ffs!” You claim the ‘Right Wing’ press is promoting, is it?
Whilst your putting me right on this can you also answer me on my points and examples I cited re: how this government filling roles with like minded people is any different to any other administration. from your thread ‘The Vote Leave Party’. You seem to have forgotten to, for some reason!
‘Left wing press’ - I’ve linked to a DeMonrford University study and a report in the Lancet!
My opinion, the argument government behaviour and decisions and those media outlets that are friendly to them have no influence on many people’s behaviour is naive. It will certainly come as a big disappointment to them and the millions they spend to do exactly that.
Again, how did something that was reported late in May effect what people did in March and April . Please, I ask again, How, do tell.
9% of people questioned! (Many before May 20th) gave various reasons.
The opening Paragraph states “Fewer people report they followed guidance on social distancing and ‘Stay at Home’ following Dominic Cummings’ admission that he drove from London to Durham during lockdown.” Where does it state they cited Cummins? Just that there was an increase in people admitting to ignoring guidelines.
De Montfort’s report states “Across all 1,201 people interviewed in both surveys, 69 per cent of people reporting they followed government guidance at all times, while 31% reported breaking the guidance to help others, because of a personal need (e.g. work), or because they do not agree with the guidance itself.” Where does that mention the Cummins incident?
The Lancet article says their study “show that these events undermined confidence in the government to handle the pandemic specifically.” ‘Undermined confidence in the government’ NOT made them break the rules or affect their view of them.
Now, point me in the direction of the “Right Wing” press which are “hailing Christmas is back on / saved ffs!”. Or shall you ignore that as “usual”.
This reply was composed before your edit where you cut some personal response and you included cut and pasted a whole report. For what reason I don't know as we can all read the report from the link, thanks.
Neither report follows left wing media. I posted two reports from reputable sources. They both make it very clear who undertook them. They both report a decline in sticking to the rules after Cummings saga. Now you can dismiss or argue your theories why that may have occurred but the reports are more informed than those who for whatever reason want to completely debunk the influence Cummings rule breaking had on trust, adherence and public opinion, have offered.


