“Lack of Investment” - The Myth
#42
(11-04-2020, 02:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 09:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: Been reading a few times on here about the lack of investment in the transfer market by the owners, it’s something that gets repeated so often it becomes an accepted fact. I thought I would do a little digging to see how true it actually is...

Lai took over September 2016, so let’s look at the spend in the years building up:

(Figures courtesy of  Transfermarkt)

11/12 -  Players in: £8.2m Players out: £10m. Net Spend -£1.8m - Plus Gera and McAuley on frees.

12/13 - In: £4.5m Out: £3.3m. Net spend £1.2m - Plus Rosenberg and Yacob on frees and Lukaku loan fee & wages.

13/14 - In: £14.1m Out: £10.2m. Net spend £3.9m - Plus Anelka and Lugano on frees and Sinclair loan.

14/15 - In: £22.4m Out: £2.1m. Net spend £20.3m - Plus Lescott, Gardner, Fletcher on frees.

15/16 - In: £38.6m Out: £11.6m. Net spend £27m

16/17 - In: £34.1m Out: £24.2m. Net spend £9.9m

17/18 (Lai’s first summer window) In: £48.1m Out: £1.9m. Net spend £46.2m - Plus loans and wages for Sturridge and Gap-year Greg

18/19 (Champ) - In: £13.7m. Out: £23.9m. Net spend -£9.8m - Plus Gayle, Barnes, Tosin loan and wages.

19/20 (Champ) - In: £19.4m Out: £29.5m. Net spend -£10.2m

20/21 - In: £36.4 Out: £6.8m. Net spend £29.6m - Plus Ivanovic free and loans for Gallagher and Krov.

Conclusions:

Investment in the transfer market has not slowed down under Lai at all. Barring the two Championship seasons where we turned over an entire squad to cut costs investment has remained at the same rough level it always has. The line from the club has always been we will spend within our means and these figure demonstrate we are doing just that. This season’s slight dip in net spend could easily attributed to projected loss of revenue as a result of COVID. The money has been spent, the more pertinent question is whether it was spent well.

A further interesting quirk is that spend really jumped from 14/15 onwards, which was around the time JP first expressed keenness to sell the club.

And how much additional equity has been injected by the shareholders to purchase anything?

Cashflows are different to profits.  Hudds show a profit on Grant, but they will wait 6 years for the cash.

Too many people scream "where's the money gone, Tom" who couldn't understand cashflow vs Profit vs Net Worth if it was spoon fed to them.

Nice to know the condescending Minstrel is never far from our bored.

I'm one that believes we could have done more in the market and our owners could have helped us.

Lai could have repaid the loan he inherited from baldy - turning an asset into cash.  The cash could then have been used in the transfer market (provided the spending was in line with FFP).

Secondly, we have a contingent asset in the form of the fergie tribunal case.  This will be held as an asset and will also generate a profit.  Lai could have loaned the cash against this asset and taken the money back once the tribunal amount had been set/paid.  I'm sure the club's auditor could have been provided with enough evidence to recognise this as an asset and we could have prudently set this at £8m with a note detailing it is expected to be significantly more.

That profit and cash flow could have seen us get a couple of FBs or a holding midfielder or a forward that knows how to hold the bloody ball up top (I think this is more of an issue with Slav and his style of play tbh). 

Or we could have loaned against that contingent asset to help realise the cash much quicker.

Neither of those options would have cost Lai anything other than temporarily the ability to use the cash elsewhere, so it's not about pumping money in and spunking it aots, just about being smarter and trying to do the best for the club.

It seems the absent owner doesn't care enough to even do that or is so strapped that he can't.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
“Lack of Investment” - The Myth - by Duffers - 11-03-2020, 09:28 PM
RE: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth - by CA Baggie - 11-04-2020, 02:12 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: