09-02-2020, 05:00 AM
(09-01-2020, 07:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(09-01-2020, 07:33 PM)Dumbo Wrote:(09-01-2020, 07:00 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(09-01-2020, 06:36 PM)Dumbo Wrote:(09-01-2020, 06:21 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: We already have experience in Austin and HRK. If we're getting Grant I really don't see the point in signing Deeney.
Because Deeney is better than both HRK and Austin.
How is he better than Austin? Austin is younger and has a better goalscoring record in the Premier League in terms of both appearances and minutes played. Even if you take away the 18 goal season from Austin he still has a better minutes per goal ratio than Deeney. That's not even mentioning the fact that Deeney has a longstanding knee injury that needs to be managed and might go pop again like it did at the beginning of the season so Austin's fitness concerns are hardly an issue. Empirically Deeney is not better than Austin at the one thing you judge strikers on and we desperately need, goals.
As I've gone into before, if you take away penalties from Deeney his goalscoring record looks very average and, let's be frank, Austin is good from the spot to put it politely. I really don't see what we gain from signing Deeney and having him replace Austin, that's assuming we would be able to actually offload Austin.
How is he better than Austin?
Well, I’m going off their performances from the most recent season. Austin was poor for us and looked shot. Deeney managed 10 goals for Watford. Not bad for a relegated team. And why the dismissal of penalties? Do they not count?
I also think Deeney has more to his all round game than Austin. Austin doesn’t link play or act like a battering ram. I could see Deeney doing that job.
Deeney > Austin. I don’t care about goal records from years gone by.
Half of Deeney's goals last season came from penalties, 5 goals from open play from your leading striker is shit relegated or not.
I've removed penalties as they seriously distort Deeney's goal scoring statistics from average to mediocre and are based on the team and not Deeney winning fouls in the box, if we don't win any penalties next season (entirely possible) then Deeney being good from the spot is pretty pointless and that's pretty much the only thing going for him.
And did you watch Deeney last season? He looked so shot to the point that he made Austin look like bloody Mo Farah. You're more than welcome to read the testimonies of Watford fans if you don't believe me, he's not the same player Pulis was sniffing after. And I haven't even mentioned his dodgy knee and the need for it to be managed. If you think Austin is bad based on his fitness I can't wait till you see how out of shape Deeney is, I'm near certain that if we do get him he'll be a bigger waste of space than Anelka and I'm prepared to put a £40 to charity on it.
+1 Deeney looked shot to pieces last season. Doesn’t mean he hasn’t the temperament to push on again this season but based on how out of shape he was I wouldn’t hold my breath.
Was out for Around six weeks at start of season & was regularity in Chelmsley Town club every Saturday watching the Blues sinking pints. I would question his motivation if he moved to the Midlands.
Austin also looked lost last season but always had the excuse of having no pre season. Maybe with one now he could regain some sharpness.

