06-11-2020, 12:33 PM
(06-11-2020, 12:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(06-11-2020, 11:44 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The steep line on the graph would have been much reduced with a earlier and harder lockdown meaning that by now we could have likely been in a position to get everything back to normal as soon as possible. We didn't and are now still in that uncertain phase.
This is the last post I will make on this matter as we're simply going round in circles.
a) "The Science" did not support an earlier Lockdown. This is a FACT. Revisionism of the FACTS now does not changed what they were at that point.
b) Lockdown could have been restricted to those most at risk. The spread of the virus may have been greater, but amongst those less likely to suffer acute problems.
c) Given that community spread & asymptomatic spread appear to be so limited there's no case for keeping schools closed.
"The Science' is a phrase that the Govt will hide behind, there was an outcry at the time about Cheltenham, that is a fact. I remember this because my lad goes every year and he decided it was foolish based on what everyone knew at the time.
Lockdown being restricted to a specific group certainly wasn't something that could have been predicted, there was anecdotal evidence of it affecting the older age group in Italy but it was put down to their older average age and having a bigger old age population.
I'm pretty much there with you on the third point but the cases need to be lower. I've found the stats on hospital admissions with covid, there are still over 400 admissions a day in the UK, it is still out there and the main reason for that is there wasn't an early lockdown when being called for - see 1st point.

