06-03-2020, 08:48 AM
(06-03-2020, 08:09 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(06-02-2020, 08:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: This argument will always come back to whose liberty? When it impinges or suppresses others liberty it becomes selfish, irresponsible and unfair.
Liberty is the responsible use of freedom under the rule of law without depriving anyone else of their freedom.
If your behaviour impinges or suppresses others' liberty it is by definition illiberal behaviour. For that reason I could argue that total Lockdown has been "selfish, irresponsible & unfair", and that a targeted approach that protected the most vulnerable groups would've been preferable and resulted in minimal loss of liberty.
The emerging evidence is that Covid19 is transmitted, in the main, in hospital and care home environments (like other fatal conditions). It doesn't appear to be rife in wider society. I fear we've had our liberty stripped and our economy ruined for something which is a minimal threat to the vast majority of the population. I call that "selfish, irresponsible & unfair". You seem to be under the misapprehension that I somehow support the government in this debacle, I don't.
And in the latest news, randy Prof Neil Ferguson has admitted that the UK relied on "quite similar science" to Sweden and that the Swedish authorities had "got a long way to the same effect" of suppression without closing schools, restaurants & bars.
Selfish, irresponsible and unfair would seem to sum up our response quite well.
You are making an argument, although you don't realise it, for an earlier, more draconian lockdown. Sweden is not the example to be quoting in this instance - as their death rates per 1000 population are higher than the vast majority of European countries.
I read an article yesterday about how the Czech Govt were going about opening up their borders. Sweden and UK were the two European countries to which they were applying the strictest conditions on citizens travelling to the Czech Republic.
The idea that Sweden have somehow been a shining light in how to deal with Covid19, is one that is not shared by most European countries . So when Swedish wonder why they are not free to enjoy a weekend break in Prague, whilst their scandinavian neighbours are they may reflect on the decision their Government took.

