05-03-2020, 07:40 PM
(05-03-2020, 07:16 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:(05-03-2020, 06:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I was pretty young when we went to war in Iraq for the second time. I wasn’t particularly party political then but I did want political change when New Labour got into power but partying was far more important to me. I was disappointed with what happened with Iraq it was the end of the positive political change that imo the country saw for a few years. That said I doubt you are naive enough to believe that the Tories would have gone against Bush and refused to back the US at the time. The voting record at the time suggests not.
I also disagree that what is happening over the last few years is not to get too upset by. It is corrosive to democracy. For example Brexit was not a debate it was a built on lies (on both sides) that as you pointed out was all about belief not reason. Time will tell if it’s a positive change but there is scarce evidence it’s going to be. Pumping out false adverts on Facebook during an election isn’t trivial, neither is journalists not bothering to fact check those lies. Misdirecting people about why decisions are made at the moment is not trivial given the gravity of the pandemic.
I know I’m pissing in the wind with this but I think this quote sums things up...
Quote:The rules are simple: they lie to us, we know they're lying, they know we know they're lying, but they keep lying to us, and we keep pretending to believe them.Elena Gorokhova, A Mountain of Crumbs
I do agree with pretty much everything you said
Except...
We were all young then, we were all out 'partying', christ, I was out in America 'working' in the music industry! I first heard that we had started dropping bombs when a DJ announced it at a nightclub in Brooklyn. I didn't take much notice because I was trying to look 'cool' in front of Louise wener from sleeper. (Predictably, it didn't work.) But it doesn't mean it didn't happen and you can't just brush it under the carpet. It was 'our' party that did it. It can't just be dismissed as 'a long time ago'. After all, some of the players then are still senior in the party now!
Adding that everything was working well up to then made me smile, if you had only added that the trains were running on time we could have been in Mussolini's Italy!
It's not about being naive. It was the labour party that did it, whether or not the conservatives would have done it is irrelevant. That's the typical argument of apologists everywhere. You could use that to excuse the most shocking behaviour in history everywhere. As for the voting behaviour of the conservatives, well they were basing it on Blair's lies, weren't they? That just makes the labour leadership worse, they subverted democracy.
It all comes out as one gigantic cop-out. Sometimes you've just got to admit the truth! But of course, I didn't expect you to, which was my point.
Personally, I think Brexit was a disaster and the way it was conducted was a national embarassment, but it was 'trivial' compared to leading the country to war and killing hundreds of thousands of innocent people. What the Conservatives are doing is 'nothing' compared to that.
Essentially, in an oddly bellicose way, all I was trying to say is that it is 'pissing in the wind' because if you can't question your own standpoint, how can you expect others to question theirs?
No matter what is said, nobody listens. That's the problem, it's us, not the politicians. They've just taken advantage of our weakness.
No-one can face changing their opinion, so accepting barely believably lies and coming out with ridiculously poor excuses is better than being wrong. The truth is irrelevant so why should the journalists bother to investigate it? Why should politicians stick to it?
It's not the conservatives and it's not Labour. It's us. We've got what we deserved and we're to blame.
You are assuming I supported Labour, but at the time I was Lib Dem. I was however happy to see the back of the Conservatives. I didn’t want to vote Labour this time due to Corbyn and Momentum but frankly the choice was either wear a Villa top or a Wolves top, no other choice was a realistic option in terms of who would win in my area. I think we shall have to agree to differ about what we see is trivial because everything is trivial compared to war. However if only all debates in this side of the board were this civilised.


