04-25-2020, 06:38 PM
(04-25-2020, 06:10 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(04-25-2020, 06:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(04-25-2020, 05:59 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The trouble is someone has to play God, and I'm glad it's not me. 70M of us in lockdown for at least 7 weeks vs saving 20k lives. That's a tricky one, it's almost battlefield rules.
It’s not 20,000 it’s more than that, those are just people who were in hospital.
(04-25-2020, 06:01 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:(04-25-2020, 05:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(04-25-2020, 05:46 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: To be fair the lockdown is about managing numbers for the nhs. Those who do the scientific modelling will have much more specific breakdowns of these numbers (ie how many were from Covid, partially from Covid, or with Covid).. and far far more detail than that. Balancing future deaths against the deaths from economic damage is no easy equation, but they’ll be working this out on far more detailed models than a simple headline figure of 20k.
The headline figure set by Professor Whitty etc as a good outcome was passed weeks ago if you include deaths outside of hospitals. I hear a lot about the deaths caused by economic damage but can someone explain factually how they will match up against the deaths from Covid? It sounds like a decent argument for relaxing the lockdown but I see very little detail to back it up.
There’s very little detail for an argument either way though. But very detailed models will be used to predict it for sure. It’s not just economic damage either, for example cancer death rates will increase due to lockdown but that will be on a time lag, as there’s a current big reduction in people visiting the GP with cancer symptoms. Only in time will a percentage of these be diagnosed later than usual, this increasing the death rate from cancer but not for a few months yet.
This is only one example, but predicting these numbers of cancer deaths, alongside deaths from economic damage and other related deaths increases due to lockdown, and then factoring this against the increase in corona deaths from easing lockdown, makes it one hell of a complex equation.
The equation would be a lot easier to solve if we had any proper idea via community testing who, when and where people have the virus. That way lockdown could eased gradually and be informed. We gave up doing that and made the calculations a lot harder to work our or potentially justify.
I know it's more than 20k, Derek. I was making a point about the enormity of the decision
We are simply not being given the figures (IMO deliberately) so all we can do is guess. The latest thought is 20,000 covid19 deaths have not been recorded. This would give the UK a 40,000+ deaths to date.
This underlying illness add on has to be factored in somewhere. The best way we "the blind" can have a reasonable guess is to compare real death rate now including CV19 and expected death rate without CV19 - As we normally lose 600,000 per year that's 50,000 a month - so anything above that figure can be considered a CV19 add on. That's a better measure then any guess work by any of us experts (me included)
PS I don't want to get into future projections again thanks.

