When will the lockdown get more strict??
#69
(04-11-2020, 01:48 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-11-2020, 01:23 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Herd immunity is in conjunction with a vaccine. It’s not just let everyone get slowly and hope for the best. My figures are not made up they are what was predicted by the same experts modelling that the government has been following. That’s one of the reasons they changed tack (debatable) as the death toll was predicted to be extremely high. I understand that the measures are to enable the NHS to cope and that the virus isn’t going away soon but numbers of infections should be minimised to the maximum bit just a shrug of the shoulders and say oh well we’ve got enough capacity in staff and ventilators now everyone back to work!  

Barely a week ago people were sneering (the usual ones) at Spain and Italy’s approach and we are in course to be worse hit than them. So at some point questions should be asked as to our approach.

Yes, but my point was that herd immunity is the only solution that has evidence of actually working. What's your goal with lockdown? If it's to get rid of the virus like this at it's current state. then that has never been successful EVER. When it fails then what do you do? Do you want us to wait and hope a vaccine arrives? How long should we wait? Have a guess how many vaccines we have developed that can unilaterally wipe out all strains of a virus....

If it's to slowdown the virus then we are in agreement. 

Even more seriously, what do you suggest we do when the money runs out? The Gilts are already stuttering, the money markets are raising their rates and their's only so much we can get away with printing via the BoE. Should we starve? Do you think the populace will still stay at home? Especially if they've got dependents, not in a high risk category or suspect they've already had it.

There is no way we can last anywhere close to the 'arbitrary timeframe' of 18months for a new vaccine. So we'll have to come out eventually. Inevitably before the virus has miraculously died.

By the way, your figure of 100 000 deaths is based on what exactly? What's the scenario? Herd immunity as the only step to take? A non-mutating virus? What do you count as a C death? 
When was the figure raised? What assumptions were made? At what spectrum of the possibility does 100 000 lie? How do they stand up to what we now? What are the proposed solutions? How do they stand up to new developments, such as asymptomatic carriers?

Talking of Spain, Italy and hey, why not? France. How do you know we are going to be worse hit than them? While we're at it, how do you explain the markedly difference in fatalities between them and Germany? They all used lockdown, yet there are remarkably different results. How about Finland? How do you think they are going to do?
I can't help think you are selecting statistics, making comparisons and drawing conclusions without much rigour. 

Something that when you see it  done by politicians, you quite rightly call them out for distorting the truth.

The figure of 250,000 was modelled by Imperial College London if we did not follow what other countries had done to flatten the curve. If we relax the rules anytime soon I cannot see without adequate testing of the public how it’ll stop the virus spiking again. The idea of opening schools for example before September will only put more people at risk. Fir example how do you keep a vulnerable  member of a family safe if their siblings are told to go back to school?
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - by Derek Hardballs - 04-11-2020, 04:48 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: