(04-11-2020, 10:47 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Herd immunity only works with a vaccine otherwise you’ll looking at hundreds of thousands of deaths in the U.K. We can’t (hmm) just letting it rip through the population
Herd Immunity explanation
You're suggesting herd immunity and exclusion are an either/or question. They're not. Therefore, the death toll you're headlining with is just not true.
We haven't got a vaccine and we don't know for sure we ever will have. What happens if it mutates quicker and more often than we hope? Even if we develop a 'vaccine' it will probably not prevent infection, but will reduce the severity to suffers - rather like the flu virus. There will still be deaths, especially among the vulnerable, and the virus will continue to spread.
Whichever way, it's not definite (although likely) we'll be able to develop any sort of vaccine, so we need a plan in case.
How are you realistically going to contain the virus inside the short time we have until the money runs out? You know that people will flout the rules and that is going to get more common as time goes on. Containment to the point of extinction is unlikely to work. Especially if the amount of asymptomatic carriers proves to be correct.
It's not about 'letting it rip' through the population, it's about focusing on giving the best possible care to the most serious sufferers.
But consider your alternative. There's absolutely no evidence that 'lock-down' by itself can remove a virus once it's got to this level. It's never been done. So why are we doing it?
It's not about eradicating the virus, it's about giving us breathing time to bring down the death rate.
No solution is 'brilliant' and there will be victims, but we do need to do something. Relying on 'lock-down' , which has never worked before, whilst hoping a vaccine might be found is just doing nothing.
You're painting lock-down as the caring approach and herd immunity as the callous approach. I don't agree with this hypothesis.
In the end, lock down with a view to waiting for virus extinction will fail and still have the same result - relying on 'herd immunity'.
All we can do is slow the growth in the short term so we can care for the serious sufferers. Which is what we are doing. Anything other solution is just fantasy.

