03-15-2020, 08:02 PM
(03-15-2020, 07:43 PM)JOK Wrote:(03-15-2020, 01:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:It’s a good job because if you were, you failed miserably with your “Other experts” post. (Which seems to have disappeared apart from being saved for posterity by BBs call out)(03-15-2020, 11:46 AM)Fido Wrote:(03-15-2020, 11:37 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:(03-15-2020, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It was second news item last night on both BBC and Sky so I will post what I like. I suspect they know more than you or I.
I guarantee you that they don't. Most of the people who signed the letter are mathematicians, there's a lab technician on there, an economics lecturer and a fair few PhD students.
You're posting absolute bollocks. Just because the BBC and Sky News are posting bollocks as well doesn't give you an excuse to.
Come on, BB. If you can't use a worldwide pandemic to score political points you shouldn't be in the "wind-up" game.
I’m not trying to score political points I have a young relative who is very vulnerable so maybe I’m just a little more twitchy with our approach than others who may not. Our approach is at odds to others, so I’m not sure why it’s unreasonable to ask whether it’s the right course of action.
I have a 98 year old mother but do not feel the need to be”twitchy”, just sensible. Or feel the need to try and make political capital out of the situation.
It isn’t “unreasonable “ to question anything. What is unreasonable is being evasive. You are still waffling about whether the government should act upon the advice of your, let’s face it, beloved experts or ignore their advice and introduce measures recommend by the screaming, panicking types on social media. It’s a simple question. Saying you can’t answer that because you are “not an expert” is not good enough when you made the comment that it would rebound on the government if they followed the advice and it proved to be wrong. You clearly inferred that the government should be taking more extreme steps than the experts (the experts you hold so dear, normally) are recommending. Siting worry over a young relative is merely deflecting from your oscillating.
So, do you believe in experts or not. (That’s qualified experts not PhD students, Law grads or economy students).
JOK here’s my thoughts in a nutshell... you and I don’t know which experts and methods are correct. There are plenty of well qualified experts who disagree with our approach (not just PHD students) so it would be arrogant to suggest we know best. The reason I’m not saying how well we are dealing with the situation is because I don’t know if we are or not and with respect neither do you. I can see some sense in our approach, but I can also see sense in what others have done. I’m calm but still nervous and I don’t see a contradiction in stating that. Saying it’s not good enough for me to suggest the government will face a backlash if they’ve called this wrong isn’t party political it’s an observation of human nature. You can disagree but to be genuinely honest I hope you are right and that our approach is best.

