03-09-2020, 03:12 PM
(03-09-2020, 02:59 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:There is nothing wrong with civil servants giving balanced dispassionate advice. The problem is that there often - I stress this, often - an entrenchment of views that lead to ministers not being given such advice or to resist change. The Civil Service frequently thinks it IS the government/state. I'm not sure what the answer is.(03-09-2020, 02:38 PM)hudds Wrote: From the left, I have some agreement with proth: the inertia and resistance to change is always a problem.
I have direct experience of a government minister agreeing a policy change on downstream oils supply that would give better front end fuel resilience only to be stymied by senior Treasury civil servants who simply feared change; they could give no legal or rational reasons to resist. I had to beat them up in meetings and go to law (and won at FTT). This is just one example of how they behave.
I understand that and yes high ranking civil servants have a reputation for being against change and quite conservative (in the non political way).
However that is not necessarily a bad thing. Sometimes that conservatism can be useful in highlighting potential problems in new policies and it would be wrong if they failed to do this or felt inhibited from doing this by an overbearing Government minister.
Sometimes there is a good reason why something has always been done a certain way.
Ultimate decision making has to be in the hands of the Government minister but they need to be able to seek avice from all quarters and take that advice where appropriate.
The funniest thing I came across where the civil service got undermined was from within. When I was in HMCE policy, the Treasury (and alcohol branch in HMCE) would not accept the case from the smaller brewers (SIBA) for progressive beer duty (and HMCE was strongly opposed to it). I had some sympathy with the case but it was not my side of things at that time. I left HMCE in late 1997; I was astounded a few years later to hear about the introduction by Gordon Brown of progressive beer duty to benefit small brewers. I asked a late former colleague and friend in Alcohol Policy how on earth Gordon Brown had been persuaded to enact this provision. My friend told me “it was that bastard Damian McBride who shafted us”. Damian McBride was a former HMCE fast streamer who ended up at the Treasury and became Gordon Brown’s confidante and attack dog. Later, McBride went too far in his “black arts” and was sacked. It was the enmity between my friend and McBride that led to McBride working relentlessly with SIBA to defeat HMCE Policy to get Brown to agree to small brewers’ reduced duty rates. As McBride says in his book “Power Trip”:
“I was particularly despised by the Manchester-based team Customs team which administered alcohol duties, and – almost to spite them one year – I started asking questions about… small brewers relief. It had always been resisted by HMCE and the Treasury because it was literally such small beer: why introduce complexity into the system just to hold back inevitable market forces? ….This became, without doubt, my finest hour as a civil servant. Working with SIBA, I personally drove through the measure. Customs fought me at every stage, but come Budget Day 2002, Gordon Brown was able to announce cheerily that the new relief would come in by the summer.”
It's a funny old world.

