02-16-2020, 12:20 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-16-2020, 12:21 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(02-16-2020, 11:45 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:(02-16-2020, 10:34 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: 4 - They act as though they're entitled to the anti-Tory vote
5 - As with the Tories they're party before country
6 - As with the Tories, they copy policy from other parties then don't credit them for it
7 - They hate civil liberties
8 - They're more than happy to throw the smaller parties under the bus even if it means that the Tories will win a majority
9 - They embrace nepotism
I think point 8 is particularly apposite.
Points 4 and 5 are ones that can be made about any party, probably less about Labour than other parties to be fair. For example the Scottish referendum the party definitely put the interests of the country before the parties own interests, with disastrous electoral consequences.
Not sure they are guilty of 6 and 9, there will be examples but it's not widespread.
Definitely think 7 is unfair.
No other party acts as entitled to the anti-Tory vote than Labour. There are 5 occasions post WW1 where they have shafted the Liberals/Liberal Democrats, most prominently in relation to the Lib Dem attempts at putting down Section 28 in the 1990s, the AV referendum, the 1970s crisis and the Blair ministries. And you can't accuse the Greens/SNP/Plaid Cymru for putting party before country, and the reason the Liberals/Lib Dems are now a minor party is a series of decisions from the last days of Gladstone through to 1922 not even mentioning the entire book of compromises that they made during the coalition that were not reciprocated. When have Labour been prepared to do that? Every time they've been asked to compromise for the good of the country they've sunk their feet in most recently a couple of months ago when they decided to go alone. For the Scottish referendum, other than the then backbencher Gordon Brown, what did Labour do? Scottish Labour were completely anonymous as they knew their voter base was split and the work done by Labour was done independent of the Westminster coalition, even refusing to work with their recent Holyrood coalition partners in the Lib Dems. That's not even mentioning their recent pivot towards supporting Scottish independence which is even more disastrous a pursuit than leaving the Single Market, for both England and especially Scotland.
As for thinking point 7 is unfair, strong elements opposed the works of Sir David Maxwell-Fyfe in drafting the ECHR postwar, they were in charge the first time the UK were taken to the ECHR, the HRA 1998 curbed the extent of the ECHR on British interests through British courts and that's not even mentioning the myriad of rights curbed under Blunkett, Clarke, Reid, Smith and Johnson.


