01-29-2020, 12:06 PM
(01-29-2020, 12:00 PM)MassDebater Wrote:(01-29-2020, 11:54 AM)billybassett Wrote:(01-29-2020, 11:36 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I thought we did enough last night to win but in nearly every game this season we have conceded. Though there have been games where he has earned us points, I'm beginning to come round to billybasset's view that, regrettably, Sam needs dropping.
No doubt I may be wrong - I mean I once thought Paul Mardon was "a player". If we don't drop him how do we know. Bond has has 2 clean sheets from 3 but the goal conceded against Millwall was a regulation ball into the 6yd box and a header in (again)...
A goalkeeper makes saves yes - but also provides confidence and comms to the whole defence. Foster did this - and yes made a few gaffes but overall was a positive impact. Johnstone is just not commanding or communicative. Comes for nothing so every ball has to be won by the defence - and that's just not possible.
Last night and Charlton were just 2 instances of him not commanding the box and costing us points. Just a modicum of bravery and thought and we get 6pts not 1.
Sadly I said that the first time I saw SJ between the sticks. He just feels small in goal, I honestly didn't even think he was 6', he's over 6'2" in reality, but he feels small. He has no presence, and that is as important for a keeper as being able to make saves.
I've seen Johnstone make some excellent saves, but he has been nowhere near top form of late and I have definitely seen better goalkeepers at ours.

