12-06-2019, 12:23 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-06-2019, 01:12 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(12-06-2019, 11:37 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Sorry again then BB, I'm a bit confused, what is she (Hart) being accused of then?
Advocating that those in work with learning difficulties should be paid less because they aren’t doing the same level of work as someone who is more able. The idea is the person gets enjoyment from simply doing the job and the money is secondary. I think she may have been accused of saying ‘people with learning difficulties don’t understand money’. I’m not sure that was the exact words but it’s something along those lines.
(12-06-2019, 11:43 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:(12-06-2019, 11:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(12-06-2019, 11:04 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: This is a complete misrepresentation of her point and the programme noted in the article she referred to. The essential premise is that the economic output of the work provided by people with severe learning disabilities is below their economic output, disincentivising employers from taking them on which in turn alienates the people with severe learning disabilities. A scheme that allows employers to pay below minimum wage to these employees encourages businesses to take them on, this has been introduced by other countries successfully and usually with the state partially subsiding the employers.
Hang on, those very types of business / charity funding was cut by Conservatives who argued disabled people would be better off in ‘normal’ employment. Most severely disabled people will never be able to work regardless of set-up but they still deserve a living wage as do those who could of worked within the now defunct business’s and charities the Tories got rid of. No matter how you dress this up this is an appalling attitude to take. Those aforementioned charities warned the government what the consequences of shutting their companies / pulling funding would be but they did it anyway.
Weasel words that ignores what has happened over the last nine years.
This isn't about welfare, stop conflating her point with welfare. This is about employers and employment opportunities. There's two factors that act as a deterrent: employers being deterred by pay and disabled people not being offered a sufficient support network by potential employers and recruiters. How big a role each factor plays relative to the other is up for debate, Ismail Kaji of Mencap offers a fair retort from his experience that the latter is the biggest problem, but attacking someone for being a heartless shrew when they genuinely believe their opinion will work (and is reciprocated by evidence, as per the referenced article) isn't helping anyone.
This is intrinsically linked to welfare. The idea you can encourage employers to employ disabled people in low skilled jobs for less than the minimum wage without the intervention of the state is flawed.
They get employed at a reduced rate, who stops people from being exploited? Will their carers / family suddenly find their money is stopped because they are working? Will their wages cover that expense? Can they live independently below the minimum wage?
Jobs, and welfare for this demographic are intrinsically linked. There were organisations and charities that employed people with learning difficulties that had their funding cut and the idea was the private sector would solve the problem all it did was move the problem directly to the state and families caring for disabled loved ones. The difference been many now find themselves isolated and unable to find / make ends meet even now, before the private sector starts employing people for less than the minimum wage.
(12-06-2019, 11:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: On the face of it it appears that Hart is pointing towards simply paying disabled people less to encourage employers to take them on. Is there another side to her point where she is saying that this employment could be supported by the government in the way of on the job training and an allowance to bring them back up to the minimum wage levels.
Here’s what happened

