In principle this is no different to - just as an example - the highland railway line north of Perth. Yes, it undoubtedly consumes some of Abellio's (Scotrail's) subsidy, but the alternative for all of those populations between Perth and Inverness is barely thinkable; some things just come with a cost which is worth paying purely for social reasons.
Tax and public expenditure aren't automatically bad things; historically badly managed at times, but that's a different argument. They are, for want of a better word, a couple of the various glues which hold a developed society together.
Tax and public expenditure aren't automatically bad things; historically badly managed at times, but that's a different argument. They are, for want of a better word, a couple of the various glues which hold a developed society together.

