09-25-2019, 03:55 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-25-2019, 04:11 PM by Neil Parsley.)
It was an unexpected decision. Academic lawyers were 50/50 on whether the issue is justiciable, but all but 2 )Professors Paul Craig and Ken Armstrong) thought it would be deemed to be lawful.
The Supreme Court has arguably overreached itself in:
i) declaring the matter justiciable
ii) holding that the advice to prorogue was unlawful
iii) holding that the prorogation itself is unlawful and not protected by Art IX of the Bill of Rights (1689) as a 'Parliamentary proceeding' and so immune from legal challenge
Indeed, ex-Justice Lord Sumption agrees that the Court effectively made new law. Such is the judicial exercise in the senior courts common law World. But to do so over an inherently and inescapably political matter is where the overreach comes in.
Some of the reasoning used was also highly questionable. For example, the Court said that the Case of Proclamations (1611) was a case asserting Parliamentary sovereignty. Which is odd, as Parliament didn't become supreme until after the Civil War. It also categorised the famous De Keyser and FBU cases as being about sovereignty. The reality is that both of those cases involved statutory schemes, not just the workings of Parliament and were more about the abrogation of the prerogative *by* statute.
Also the Court says that motive is not relevant when ascertaining whether the prorogation was for a 'reasonable purpose'. But you cannot demarcate 'motive' from 'reason' and a lot of the judgment around paragraph 60 is clearly discussing 'motive' under the guise of 'reasonable purpose'.
You could also suggest that the issue of whether there is a reasonable purpose is a political, not a legal, matter. The court agrees that it is a matter of fact and not law. If the case has the effect of laying-out a general principle that the prerogative powers can't be used in a way that infringes some (hitherto legally unenforceable) constitutional principle without 'reasonable purpose' that could get in the way of administration.
Another problem is that the Court did not lay-out any principles by which this 'reasonableness' can be assessed by Government. The courts could become very choc-a-block as a result.
But what the Supreme Court says is the law *is* the law. Let's see where we go from here.
PS - John Major going around calling it a disgrace when his own prorogation in 1997 would have been unlawful on yesterday's reasoning.
Remain does love a hypocrite and there's no better than Mr Back To Basics himself.
The Supreme Court has arguably overreached itself in:
i) declaring the matter justiciable
ii) holding that the advice to prorogue was unlawful
iii) holding that the prorogation itself is unlawful and not protected by Art IX of the Bill of Rights (1689) as a 'Parliamentary proceeding' and so immune from legal challenge
Indeed, ex-Justice Lord Sumption agrees that the Court effectively made new law. Such is the judicial exercise in the senior courts common law World. But to do so over an inherently and inescapably political matter is where the overreach comes in.
Some of the reasoning used was also highly questionable. For example, the Court said that the Case of Proclamations (1611) was a case asserting Parliamentary sovereignty. Which is odd, as Parliament didn't become supreme until after the Civil War. It also categorised the famous De Keyser and FBU cases as being about sovereignty. The reality is that both of those cases involved statutory schemes, not just the workings of Parliament and were more about the abrogation of the prerogative *by* statute.
Also the Court says that motive is not relevant when ascertaining whether the prorogation was for a 'reasonable purpose'. But you cannot demarcate 'motive' from 'reason' and a lot of the judgment around paragraph 60 is clearly discussing 'motive' under the guise of 'reasonable purpose'.
You could also suggest that the issue of whether there is a reasonable purpose is a political, not a legal, matter. The court agrees that it is a matter of fact and not law. If the case has the effect of laying-out a general principle that the prerogative powers can't be used in a way that infringes some (hitherto legally unenforceable) constitutional principle without 'reasonable purpose' that could get in the way of administration.
Another problem is that the Court did not lay-out any principles by which this 'reasonableness' can be assessed by Government. The courts could become very choc-a-block as a result.
But what the Supreme Court says is the law *is* the law. Let's see where we go from here.
(09-25-2019, 03:56 PM)Neil Parsley Wrote:(09-24-2019, 09:56 AM)baggy1 Wrote: When something is as obvious as what Boris did the court will intervene if asked. The court won't get involved in every petition because they can, and probably will, say that it isn't a matter for the judiciary.
Nothing like the US.
It wasn't 'as obvious' which is why the judgment has clearly created a legal earthquake.
PS - John Major going around calling it a disgrace when his own prorogation in 1997 would have been unlawful on yesterday's reasoning.
Remain does love a hypocrite and there's no better than Mr Back To Basics himself.

