09-05-2019, 09:35 AM
(09-05-2019, 09:22 AM)Sunshine Wrote:(09-05-2019, 09:01 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:(09-05-2019, 08:43 AM)baggy1 Wrote: A 2nd referendum would be phrased differently to give the MPs scope for their approach. This should have been clarified a couple of years ago when it became obvious that this was going to be a bit more difficult than the 'easiest in human history' to get.
Do you want to remain in the EU or Leave the EU? Remain ; Leave
Would you accept a No Deal Brexit? Yes ; No
If we can go to the trouble of calling an election to give a government the mandate to do what they want (which won't work because we are split down the middle and and we'll get another, probably more so, hung parliament) then we can have a referendum to clarify the matter for the current government to carry out the will of the people.
There currently isn't a mandate in the country for no deal, a referendum will do one of three things; give Boris the mandate to take us out with no deal; cancel Brexit entirely, mean that the government have to do some work and negotiate a proper deal.
This 'ability to walk away' line as a requirement comes from people who understand business but don't understand government. Running the country isn't the same as running a PLC. A PLC can walk away from a deal because they will move onto another deal to replace the one they don't like. We can't walk away from the EU, we need to continue to work with them going forward.
B1, I know we don’t agree, fundamentally, but I do appreciate that you do talk sensibly. Without the antagonistic bile that some use. I can agree with some of what you say here but As regards not running a state the same as a PLC... The Kennedy intransigent stand off with Khrushchev eventually produced an agreement acceptable to both sides.
However we live under a parliamentary democracy not a presidential one.
BJ has not learnt from the failings of his predecessor, whatever plan he has can be blocked by parliament.
Exactly, the stupidity of not gauging what Parliament would accept, the practicalities of those positions and devising a plan of action for the negotiations before activating Article 50 is what led to May's downfall and Boris is just doing the same thing with the same empty rhetoric.

