08-23-2019, 08:04 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-23-2019, 08:08 PM by Johnnykayeengland.)
(08-23-2019, 02:07 PM)baggy1 Wrote:Good point!(08-23-2019, 01:59 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I know it's personal opinion, but some strange choices here... Madonna?!
What about Joni!
Surely only one person counts, though, in this list (not my favourite, particularly). But Dylan redefined singer- songwriting. Noone was doing it anything like that. Then suddenly everyone was.
The problem I have with labelling Dylan as a great singer-songwriter is the singer element of it. Great songs but fuck me his voice is an acquired taste.
Have you heard" Girl from the North Country" duette with Johnny cash?
Wonderful song. Dreadful interpretation!
(08-23-2019, 01:32 PM)baggy1 Wrote:Macca tells a great story about their partnership.(08-23-2019, 01:27 PM)Ed Hopper Wrote:(08-23-2019, 01:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You see this Lennon and McCartney wrote together line is a bit of a myth, they both have very individual sounds that they brought to the table especially after about Rubber Soul. The only reason they are listed together is because of the music rights and the company they set up.
Have a listen to the solo albums straight after the break up and compare them to the last few albums - you'd be able to work out who wrote which song using the post Beatles stuff as a measuring stick.
That is very true-but without Lennon, McCartney would have got more of his ‘dross’ through, and without McCartney, Lennon would have likewise.
They wrote songs individually, but getting that song to the recording stage often was a result of the band agreeing to it. There’s always exceptions, like Yesterday or Blackbird, that are pretty much all McCartney. But they needed each other as competition, and a filter.
I’m a massive McCartney fan, but have to admit that he could have done with John around to give him a dose of realism with some of his solo/wings stuff. But because McCartney’s nature was so forceful, he preferred to surround himself with sycophants like Denny Lane who were just happy to be in the same band as him, and say ‘yes paul’ a lot!
Agreed Ed, I'd add that I think the battle between McCartney and Lennon was the reason for so much of the crap that came out of their immediate solo work. From 'McCartney' I'd only pick Maybe I'm Amazed for my Black Album and the rest was navel gazing crap, Imagine and Jealous Guy from Lennon's first solo and that is why Harrison cleaned up early doors - they were too focussed on their divorce.
Have you read 'You never gave me your money' - good read if you like that stuff. It's a bit hard to start because of all the detail but it is a real insight.
He came with a great song, "I saw her Standing There".
But his line was ... "She was just 17, Looked like a teenage queen..."
Lennon said "She was just 17, You know what I mean..."
Genius!


