08-19-2019, 02:14 PM
(08-17-2019, 10:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(08-17-2019, 09:56 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Could they not do an appeal system like cricket and tennis?
Review system in football doesn’t work as there are so few decisions compared to cricket and tennis... every goal that got scored would be reviewed and it would take away the fans’ enjoyment... further it takes away the authority of the ref, which current VAR rules have been formulated to maintain.
I’m a little confused about the complaints around the City game... the penalty in the first half wasn’t a clear and obvious error so it wasn’t flagged. VAR May have said to the ref to review it but he will have decided not to, or the VAR team decided it wasn’t clear enough to review... penalties are still subjective. People complain when decisions are reviewed and when they’re not...
The goal that was correctly ruled out wasn’t subjective. There was a handball (albeit accidental) in the buildup to the goal which by the letter of the law was a foul. As soon as we start deciding “oh this objective foul isn’t a foul” it opens a load of new inconsistency.
I’m not a fan of the new handball rule, but that’s not VAR’s fault.
Every goal is already checked anyway and it’s obvious that play continues when there may have been an off-side or handball. The ref then just defers to the VAR.
The new hand ball rule is pathetic and needs changing ASAP. I think this has been brought in to aid VAR, makes handball a factual event that can be spotted by a camera when intent is much more of an instinctive decision.
Goal line technology works, VAR doesn’t. How does the Man City pen claim fall into “wasn’t clear and obvious” and therefore VAR doesn’t count but then is used to pick up the minutest mm of offside or brush of an arm hair? That too isn’t “clear and obvious”.
I’m glad we’re in the Champo to give VAR a season to either change or be scrapped before we join the circus next season!

