08-19-2019, 10:24 AM
Lots has been made of Shan's failure to sub Gayle.
Dawson went off at HT. Phillips went off after an hour so we had him available for the second leg. This was clearly pre-planned. Johansen's calf tightened and he had to go off. Shan would have known Johansen might not last the 90.
Hooking Gayle after 80 minutes would have meant we finished with 10 for the last 5 minutes plus stoppage time, with Villa in the ascendancy. I'm convinced that he would've taken Gayle off, but for the unexpected Dawson sub. If we had conceded a third in stoppage time with 10 men through our own choice, what would the judgement have been on Shan for taking Gayle off?
It's all very easy with hindsight and we can also use that to say we ended up with 10 men anyway, but I think there would've been a very different judgement passed if that had been caused by our subs.
Dawson went off at HT. Phillips went off after an hour so we had him available for the second leg. This was clearly pre-planned. Johansen's calf tightened and he had to go off. Shan would have known Johansen might not last the 90.
Hooking Gayle after 80 minutes would have meant we finished with 10 for the last 5 minutes plus stoppage time, with Villa in the ascendancy. I'm convinced that he would've taken Gayle off, but for the unexpected Dawson sub. If we had conceded a third in stoppage time with 10 men through our own choice, what would the judgement have been on Shan for taking Gayle off?
It's all very easy with hindsight and we can also use that to say we ended up with 10 men anyway, but I think there would've been a very different judgement passed if that had been caused by our subs.

