Left Wing politics at its most juvenile
#21
(10-05-2026, 10:14 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 06:51 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-04-2026, 09:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Personally I think a belief in a 2-state solution is a ludicrous as any of the sky fairies either side purports to believe in.

The Palestinians had their opportunities, and their leaders rejected them. Why? Because without the perpetual conflict they have nothing.

1. The PA and by extension the Palestinian state that we recognise as part of the two-state solution support the two-state solution.

2. This is literally the argument from the other arse cheek used to justify the anti-Semitic motion and is used by the Israeli far right to justify their own campaigns of terror within and without Israel.

History suggests I'm right and your not though. However much western liberals dress it up there is zero chance of a functioning democratic Palestinian state at permanent peace with Israel. 

Don't get me wrong, I think it would be wonderful but chances of it happening are beyond negligible.

Eh? How does it?
Reply
#22
(10-05-2026, 04:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Eh? How does it?

1947 UN Partition Plan
Rejection not just of a 2-state solution by Arab Leaders, but of Jewish sovereignty entirely. Followed by war.

1967 After 6 days war Israel signals willingness to exchange land for peace. Arab League declares No Peace, No Recognition, No Negotiation. 

2000 Camp David Accords
Ehud Barak offers Gaza, over 90% of the West Bank and East Jerusalem as the Palestinian capital. Arafat rejects the deal without making a counter offer.

2008 Olmert Proposal
Olmert offers even more land, land swaps, refugee resettlement and a joint administration of Jerusalem. Abbas rejects the deal without making a counter offer.

2020 Trump Plan
PA refuses to engage entirely. Why? Well this might help you: https://www.washingtoninstitute.org/poli...ompromises - they're only reflecting what their people think.

What else could you conclude from this than that Palestinian Leaders are not interested in a two-state solution? It's a western liberal pipe-dream which ignores the fact that one side has repeatedly walked away.
Reply
#23
And as of 2026 the PA endorses the two-state solution and cooperates with the Israeli state on security matters in the West Bank which entirely contradicts your point. Jordan and Egypt endorse the two-state solution. Syria has opened up diplomatic channels with Israel despite the Golan Heights. What you've posted is irrelevant to the current situation.

What you're saying is the same light as saying that modern Western European relations would never happen because of historic Franco-German relations from Prussia right up to WWII.
Reply
#24
(10-05-2026, 04:58 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And as of 2026 the PA endorses the two-state solution and cooperates with the Israeli state on security matters in the West Bank which entirely contradicts your point. 

There is no viable two-state proposal on the table. 

So whatever the wholly illegitimate PA says it means nothing. 

Nice of them to think of having their first election in a couple of decades this year though - even if it's not to replace the 90 year old Abbas. Do you think the inhabitants opposition to a two-state solution has softened in the last couple of years? I doubt it personally.
Reply
#25
There is no two-state solution currently on the table because the current Israeli government opposes it. It takes two to tango. You referenced Olmert above, do you remember why that was taken off the table? The PA and Israeli government were still in negotiations right up until Olmert left office, someone else called them off. What was his name again?
Reply
#26
(10-05-2026, 04:58 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And as of 2026 the PA endorses the two-state solution and cooperates with the Israeli state on security matters in the West Bank which entirely contradicts your point. Jordan and Egypt endorse the two-state solution. Syria has opened up diplomatic channels with Israel despite the Golan Heights. What you've posted is irrelevant to the current situation.

What you're saying is the same light as saying that modern Western European relations would never happen because of historic Franco-German relations from Prussia right up to WWII.

This analogy is one of the worst I've ever seen on here and makes no sense, in fact the two situations are completely non-analogous.

Aside from that, the PA is a paper tiger, no elections since 2005 and considering the geography of Area A, their rule is only really secure in Ramallah. Their co-operation with the IDF is necessary to keep them in power. As intimated, they already don't control vast swathes of the West Bank as it is.

There will be no return to the table for talks of a two-state solution following the events of October 7th without full demilitarisation of the other factions involved. The PA has no authority over either Hamas or PIJ or indeed dozens of other militia groups. It's a total non-starter.
Reply
#27
(10-05-2026, 09:04 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 04:58 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And as of 2026 the PA endorses the two-state solution and cooperates with the Israeli state on security matters in the West Bank which entirely contradicts your point. Jordan and Egypt endorse the two-state solution. Syria has opened up diplomatic channels with Israel despite the Golan Heights. What you've posted is irrelevant to the current situation.

What you're saying is the same light as saying that modern Western European relations would never happen because of historic Franco-German relations from Prussia right up to WWII.

This analogy is one of the worst I've ever seen on here and makes no sense, in fact the two situations are completely non-analogous.

Aside from that, the PA is a paper tiger, no elections since 2005 and considering the geography of Area A, their rule is only really secure in Ramallah. Their co-operation with the IDF is necessary to keep them in power. As intimated, they already don't control vast swathes of the West Bank as it is.

There will be no return to the table for talks of a two-state solution following the events of October 7th without full demilitarisation of the other factions involved. The PA has no authority over either Hamas or PIJ or indeed dozens of other militia groups. It's a total non-starter.

Do you think that if you go back in 1939 and say within 30 years France and Germany will be in a voluntary economic union and not be laughed at? That is centuries of violent direct conflict right there to being cooperative neighbours with sovereignty over the Saarland and Alsace-Lorraine being sorted. It is perfectly analogous.

And the two-state solution is off the table because the Israeli government does not want it to be on the table, because the current Israeli PM has personally championed himself as being opposed to it. Hamas and PIJ are not the subject of negotiations, they are not and were not the recognised authority that Israel had been negotiating with for 4 years prior to the 2009 election.
Reply
#28
Correct. Suggesting Abbas & the PA have any legitimacy is laughable.
Reply
#29
(10-05-2026, 09:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Correct. Suggesting Abbas & the PA have any legitimacy is laughable.

You'll have to explain that to Olmert and Lapid then, I think they know more about this than you.
Reply
#30
Then they probably also know that Hamas is the de facto leadership in Gaza, and nothing the wholly illegitimate PA says or does will change that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)