Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(09-07-2026, 09:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: You wouldn't criticise Phillips for not having the passing ability of Xavi, would you? Or criticise Diakité for not being able to chip in with the odd 20 yard screamer from midfield, would you?
You wouldn't because that's not their game, or what they're being asked to do.
So why would you criticise Heggebø for not scoring more goals, when that's not his game, where his strengths lie, or what he's being asked to do?
He's clearly in the team to perform a specific role. Whilst I accept his finishing could improve, that's not what he should be truly judged on. If he has games where he can't hold the ball up, bring others in to play, and genuinely doesn't make himself a nuisance, that's when criticism would be fair - as that's what you should expect of him.
Josh, he's a striker we spent over £3m on when we were skint. Strikers deal in goals, he'll always be judged harshly if he doesn't score them regardless of the other qualities he brings to the side.
Fair. I like him a lot and really want him to do well, but a non-scoring striker is always going to get harsh feedback.
I was more annoyed by the idiot in the East Stand giving Price pelters. Virtually everything good we did on Saturday came via Price.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-07-2026, 09:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: You wouldn't criticise Phillips for not having the passing ability of Xavi, would you? Or criticise Diakité for not being able to chip in with the odd 20 yard screamer from midfield, would you?
You wouldn't because that's not their game, or what they're being asked to do.
So why would you criticise Heggebø for not scoring more goals, when that's not his game, where his strengths lie, or what he's being asked to do?
He's clearly in the team to perform a specific role. Whilst I accept his finishing could improve, that's not what he should be truly judged on. If he has games where he can't hold the ball up, bring others in to play, and genuinely doesn't make himself a nuisance, that's when criticism would be fair - as that's what you should expect of him.
Josh, he's a striker we spent over £3m on when we were skint. Strikers deal in goals, he'll always be judged harshly if he doesn't score them regardless of the other qualities he brings to the side.
He was brought in to do more than score goals… the fact we have brain dead fans who can’t appreciate what he brings to the team isn’t his fault.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(09-07-2026, 09:28 AM)Squid Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: You wouldn't criticise Phillips for not having the passing ability of Xavi, would you? Or criticise Diakité for not being able to chip in with the odd 20 yard screamer from midfield, would you?
You wouldn't because that's not their game, or what they're being asked to do.
So why would you criticise Heggebø for not scoring more goals, when that's not his game, where his strengths lie, or what he's being asked to do?
He's clearly in the team to perform a specific role. Whilst I accept his finishing could improve, that's not what he should be truly judged on. If he has games where he can't hold the ball up, bring others in to play, and genuinely doesn't make himself a nuisance, that's when criticism would be fair - as that's what you should expect of him.
Josh, he's a striker we spent over £3m on when we were skint. Strikers deal in goals, he'll always be judged harshly if he doesn't score them regardless of the other qualities he brings to the side.
Fair. I like him a lot and really want him to do well, but a non-scoring striker is always going to get harsh feedback.
I was more annoyed by the idiot in the East Stand giving Price pelters. Virtually everything good we did on Saturday came via Price.
I'll caveat my comments by saying that Heggebo should still be good for 8-10 goals, which playing alongisde others like Price (8-10) and JJM (10-15+) means it's much less of an issue. It was wholly made worse by Mason playing him without support and running him into the ground last season. I like Heggebo, but you can't blame people for complaining that we've paid good money for a striker, at a time when we're not flush with cash who doesn't look like and hasn't ever been a prolific goalscorer.
You're right on Price, btw. If you don't rate Price then I'm afraid you're past help.
Posts: 7,725
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(09-07-2026, 09:28 AM)Squid Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: You wouldn't criticise Phillips for not having the passing ability of Xavi, would you? Or criticise Diakité for not being able to chip in with the odd 20 yard screamer from midfield, would you?
You wouldn't because that's not their game, or what they're being asked to do.
So why would you criticise Heggebø for not scoring more goals, when that's not his game, where his strengths lie, or what he's being asked to do?
He's clearly in the team to perform a specific role. Whilst I accept his finishing could improve, that's not what he should be truly judged on. If he has games where he can't hold the ball up, bring others in to play, and genuinely doesn't make himself a nuisance, that's when criticism would be fair - as that's what you should expect of him.
Josh, he's a striker we spent over £3m on when we were skint. Strikers deal in goals, he'll always be judged harshly if he doesn't score them regardless of the other qualities he brings to the side.
Fair. I like him a lot and really want him to do well, but a non-scoring striker is always going to get harsh feedback.
I was more annoyed by the idiot in the East Stand giving Price pelters. Virtually everything good we did on Saturday came via Price.
As I said earlier, the actual IQ Test.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(09-07-2026, 09:31 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: You wouldn't criticise Phillips for not having the passing ability of Xavi, would you? Or criticise Diakité for not being able to chip in with the odd 20 yard screamer from midfield, would you?
You wouldn't because that's not their game, or what they're being asked to do.
So why would you criticise Heggebø for not scoring more goals, when that's not his game, where his strengths lie, or what he's being asked to do?
He's clearly in the team to perform a specific role. Whilst I accept his finishing could improve, that's not what he should be truly judged on. If he has games where he can't hold the ball up, bring others in to play, and genuinely doesn't make himself a nuisance, that's when criticism would be fair - as that's what you should expect of him.
Josh, he's a striker we spent over £3m on when we were skint. Strikers deal in goals, he'll always be judged harshly if he doesn't score them regardless of the other qualities he brings to the side.
He was brought in to do more than score goals… the fact we have brain dead fans who can’t appreciate what he brings to the team isn’t his fault.
See my comments back to Squid above. I don't disagree Dekka.
Posts: 8,005
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
I think, yet again, the sanctimony of the "elite", needs to be reigned in. Maybe actually read the first line of the thread and the subsequent responses. Heggebo has received far more praise than criticism, yet some still "need" to come across as superior.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-07-2026, 09:41 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I think, yet again, the sanctimony of the "elite", needs to be reigned in. Maybe actually read the first line of the thread and the subsequent responses. Heggebo has received far more praise than criticism, yet some still "need" to come across as superior.
Just accept all players have strengths and weaknesses, the only time I can see any merit in overly criticising players is if they aren’t putting in any effort, or they’ve stopped doing the things they are good at.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(09-07-2026, 09:26 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: You wouldn't criticise Phillips for not having the passing ability of Xavi, would you? Or criticise Diakité for not being able to chip in with the odd 20 yard screamer from midfield, would you?
You wouldn't because that's not their game, or what they're being asked to do.
So why would you criticise Heggebø for not scoring more goals, when that's not his game, where his strengths lie, or what he's being asked to do?
He's clearly in the team to perform a specific role. Whilst I accept his finishing could improve, that's not what he should be truly judged on. If he has games where he can't hold the ball up, bring others in to play, and genuinely doesn't make himself a nuisance, that's when criticism would be fair - as that's what you should expect of him.
Exactly, it is a test of football knowledge/intelligence, exactly as the Brunt test was. It’s akin to criticising Yacob for not being creative, or Brunt for lacking pace.
Heggebo is in the team to create space for others, to bring others into play, tire the opposition centre halves, allow us to play further up the field, and to chip in with goals. That’s his game and he’s very good at it. I’m sure he would like to score more goals but its not the key attribute to what he brings to a team and I imagine other players around him, appreciate his contribution.
It amazes me how some fans can watch football for decades and still don’t have a clue what they are on about…
Exactly.
Posts: 8,005
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(09-07-2026, 10:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:41 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I think, yet again, the sanctimony of the "elite", needs to be reigned in. Maybe actually read the first line of the thread and the subsequent responses. Heggebo has received far more praise than criticism, yet some still "need" to come across as superior.
Just accept all players have strengths and weaknesses, the only time I can see any merit in overly criticising players is if they aren’t putting in any effort, or they’ve stopped doing the things they are good at. Again.
You seem to focus entirely on his strengths and refer to anyone calling out his weaknesses as "braindead". Maybe take your own advise.
Do you think for one second that Mozza, Gill and co. are not looking at ways to improve Heggebo's goal output? Of course they are, as, I'm sure, is the man himself.
Posts: 306
Threads: 6
Joined: Jan 2026
Reputation:
1
(09-07-2026, 09:41 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I think, yet again, the sanctimony of the "elite", needs to be reigned in. Maybe actually read the first line of the thread and the subsequent responses. Heggebo has received far more praise than criticism, yet some still "need" to come across as superior.
I like this post.
I also like Heggebo, and have said so elsewhere.
I also think that he has limitations to his game. I guess that's back to the old adage of "...if he was any good he wouldn't be playing for us" that gets trotted out.
He's OK; industrious, a trier, a wrestler of centre halves who seems to enjoy being here and is a good lad. His family are probably decent Norwegian types too. Can't shoot for shit though.
|