Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final
(05-21-2026, 08:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 08:29 AM)sickParrot Wrote: Now that the EFL process is over, the FA could get involved and ban anyone involved for 12 months.

And this is where I'd draw the line. 

Eckhert has actually been surprisingly open about this, accepted responsibility and said he did it having done it on the continent and being unaware of the rules here. I do believe that whilst cheating needs to be punished, his motivation was done through mistakenly believing it was allowed. He's a young coach, in his first managerial job and working under pressure. He will lose his job this week, and his reputation is in tatters in the UK, I don't see the need to punish him with a ban. He will be untouchable for 12 months at least in the British game anyway.

I think they hand him a fine, and let him get on with his career. His next job will be back in France or Germany regardless of whether the FA ban him in England or not.

Im not disagreeing with the post, but not knowing rules is piss poor excuse at this level.

It’s difficult to believe this only involved the manager and one scout, that nobody else at the club questioned what was going on, and that not one of them knew the rules.

Looks like the FA are getting involved
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/art...mplprldl8o
Reply
Without getting political, the idea that everyone does it so it's okay is, I believe, one of the key problems of this society.  It's also why we get such dodgy politicians of all sides.

It doesn't matter if someone else got away with it. It's not an excuse to do something you know is wrong. Excusing it like this just encourages more and worse misbehaviour.

If it really is true that others do it - and we don't know that for sure - I can bet they all justify it by everyone else does it. 

Well, they won't do it anymore!

Now onto my theories about how to stop the wrestling and grappling at corners...
Reply
(05-21-2026, 08:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 08:29 AM)sickParrot Wrote: Now that the EFL process is over, the FA could get involved and ban anyone involved for 12 months.

And this is where I'd draw the line. 

Eckhert has actually been surprisingly open about this, accepted responsibility and said he did it having done it on the continent and being unaware of the rules here. I do believe that whilst cheating needs to be punished, his motivation was done through mistakenly believing it was allowed. He's a young coach, in his first managerial job and working under pressure. He will lose his job this week, and his reputation is in tatters in the UK, I don't see the need to punish him with a ban. He will be untouchable for 12 months at least in the British game anyway.

I think they hand him a fine, and let him get on with his career. His next job will be back in France or Germany regardless of whether the FA ban him in England or not.

He was at Barnsley when Leeds got caught out doing it, I find that a weak excuse
Reply
(05-21-2026, 08:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: @SW4 - The EFL didn't decide the punishment, it was an independent panel, wasn't it? Did the EFL push for the expulsion verdict, or have they remained neutral?

My comment about changing rules retrospectively was a tongue in cheek joke aimed at their shenanigans with our PSR breach, it wasn't meant as a serious suggestion!

I still believe the punishment is disproportionate, but I'm not sure what other punishment would suffice. A fine, regardless of amount, doesn't seem to be enough, a points deduction for next season wouldn't be relevant to this, so I can understand the logic of expelling them from the play-offs, I genuinely understand that, I don't agree with it, as it doesn't feel right to me, but then again, as I've just said, any other punishment wouldn't feel right in terms of not being enough.

It's a messy situation, and I could honestly understand why any team involved would seek legal action, from Saints, to Boro and Hull, I could see logic in the arguments each team would bring.

All this confusion, uncertainty, the creation of a shit show, before you go into fans buying tickets/booking hotels etc etc, for negligible advantage gain. I just can't understand why Southampton have risked so much. It's brain-dead on their part.
Josh, you have vehemently insisted that the punishment is disproportionate. Many of us on here don't agree with you and believe it has been fairly handled. 

Maybe you should have approached the ''Saints'' and ask to represent them in their appeal! Big Grin
Reply
(05-21-2026, 09:32 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 08:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 08:29 AM)sickParrot Wrote: Now that the EFL process is over, the FA could get involved and ban anyone involved for 12 months.

And this is where I'd draw the line. 

Eckhert has actually been surprisingly open about this, accepted responsibility and said he did it having done it on the continent and being unaware of the rules here. I do believe that whilst cheating needs to be punished, his motivation was done through mistakenly believing it was allowed. He's a young coach, in his first managerial job and working under pressure. He will lose his job this week, and his reputation is in tatters in the UK, I don't see the need to punish him with a ban. He will be untouchable for 12 months at least in the British game anyway.

I think they hand him a fine, and let him get on with his career. His next job will be back in France or Germany regardless of whether the FA ban him in England or not.

He was at Barnsley when Leeds got caught out doing it, I find that a weak excuse

I wasn’t aware of that, it does change the picture somewhat. 

I think you and Sickparrot raise good points, and I could understand the FA handing him a ban, I just think if they come down hard on him despite the fact he’s openly confessed to it, it deters people from confessing.
Reply
I don't see how forfeiting a match and a 4 point deduction is disproportionate? Tough titty that the forfeit is in a PO semi and costs you a Wembley trip.

They have NOT been fined a single penny. Saying it's cost them £200m means you are completely discounting Hull, and are assuming they'd have won.

If a team gets caught spying now then I'm pretty sure they'll lose the match 3-0 and get a 1 point deduction. Which when put like that, sounds fair, no?
Reply
The £2M " fine" is a red herring. Cheating normally results in expulsion. It's that simple.
Reply
(05-21-2026, 09:43 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Josh, you have vehemently insisted that the punishment is disproportionate. Many of us on here don't agree with you and believe it has been fairly handled. 

Maybe you should have approached the ''Saints'' and ask to represent them in their appeal! Big Grin

And that's my genuine opinion, I am fully aware I'm in the minority. I don't like people, anyway, I'm fine being on my own Big Grin

I did type out a post detailing what I'd have done as punishment, but chose not to post, it didn't feel enough, and the expulsion seems too much. I really don't know what would be a fitting punishment. Whatever position I think about, it doesn't seem a fitting outcome. Every scenario seems to create more issues and questions - I'm clearly being dense here! 

What I do know is that Saints are definitely cheats, there's no arguments there from anyone, and this is a messy situation where whatever outcome happens from here on in, will open a can of warms, if they're not already opened. 

Utter shit show.

(05-21-2026, 09:59 AM)MrBater Wrote: I don't see how forfeiting a match and a 4 point deduction is disproportionate? Tough titty that the forfeit is in a PO semi and costs you a Wembley trip.

They have NOT been fined a single penny. Saying it's cost them £200m means you are completely discounting Hull, and are assuming they'd have won.

If a team gets caught spying now then I'm pretty sure they'll lose the match 3-0 and get a 1 point deduction. Which when put like that, sounds fair, no?

It's like getting to the last two boxes on Deal or No Deal, and ending up with 1p after refusing the Bankers offer of the swap, while the banker has £250k. You haven't lost £250k, you never owned it, but it does feel like you've made a collosal fuck up.
Reply
(05-21-2026, 10:26 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: The £2M " fine" is a red herring. Cheating normally results in expulsion. It's that simple.

Exactly. If someone tried to cheat in the village baking competition, they'd get disqualified from it. It's really not a difficult concept to grasp.
Reply
(05-21-2026, 10:35 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 10:26 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: The £2M " fine" is a red herring.  Cheating normally results in expulsion. It's that simple.

Exactly. If someone tried to cheat in the village baking competition, they'd get disqualified from it. It's really not a difficult concept to grasp.

I'm still pissed off at that throbber on Bake Off, the one year. They clearly sabotaged a baked Alaska by taking it out of the freezer when it was ridiculously hot, weather wise. 

Proper cunts trick. She didn't get disqualified, she was allowed to carry on in the competition. She got her comeuppance, though.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)