Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final
(05-19-2026, 04:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: According to my mate who is a Saints ST and well connected in their supporters association, they’ve just given them an extra allocation of tickets for Wembley!

Hi CIM.
Reply
(05-19-2026, 08:53 PM)baggpuss Wrote: Points deduction for Soton next season?

4 points.

Saints appeal hearing tomorrow, I think they’ll still be at Wembley on Saturday.
Reply
Nah. They won’t.
Raw Sausage
Reply
I’m surprised they haven’t come to the conclusion yet that nobody gets promoted from the play offs so we can save West Ham and Spurs
Reply
(05-19-2026, 08:59 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(05-19-2026, 08:55 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-19-2026, 08:49 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(05-19-2026, 08:22 PM)CIM Wrote:
(05-19-2026, 07:41 PM)Lightnin Wrote: What happens when Boro beat Hull now. That’ll be Southampton, Hull and Wrexham appealing.

Why the fugg would Wrexham appeal?

Now Saints have been thrown out of the play-offs then it's logical that Wrexham could take their place, after finishing 7th? At least it's logical in my mind! 

Boro have had a free ticket to the final, despite losing over two legs, and you could argue that they should have to earn it. I.e play a semi-final against another team that hasn't cheated. 

I am aware that's probably convoluted, and a line has to be drawn somewhere. I also understand, and think the argument of 'Saints cheated against Boro, so they effectively lose the tie 3-0 via forfeit' is a reasonable one. 

It's all very messy, isn't it?

Wrexham didn’t make the playoffs over 46 games, why should they suddenly be put in the playoffs because Saints cheated after they’d qualified?

Boro would then have to play 4 games to reach the final, after Hull have only played 2, and Wrexham could reach it through only playing 2, despite Boro being the victims of the cheating?

Saints broke the rules and have been thrown out. As with every other case where a team cheats in a knock out game, the opposition gets a by into the final.

All reasonable and fair points. 

Saints being expelled from the play-offs effectively means all teams are bumped up one place in my mind, so Wrexham would be the 6th team - that's where I was coming from.

What utter crap there is only one team been cheated and it certainly isn’t ReynoldsTown. Middlesbrough should play against Hull,even though Hull are now moaning they have prepared for Saints.Hull want saints because they’ve beaten them twice.
Just get this over and done with.
Reply
This sort of spying fully deserving of a points deduction, and his balls chopped off.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/art...2p1pl13j0o
Reply
(05-19-2026, 09:00 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(05-19-2026, 04:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: According to my mate who is a Saints ST and well connected in their supporters association, they’ve just given them an extra allocation of tickets for Wembley!

Hi CIM.

Big Grin

(05-19-2026, 08:59 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(05-19-2026, 08:55 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-19-2026, 08:49 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(05-19-2026, 08:22 PM)CIM Wrote:
(05-19-2026, 07:41 PM)Lightnin Wrote: What happens when Boro beat Hull now. That’ll be Southampton, Hull and Wrexham appealing.

Why the fugg would Wrexham appeal?

Now Saints have been thrown out of the play-offs then it's logical that Wrexham could take their place, after finishing 7th? At least it's logical in my mind! 

Boro have had a free ticket to the final, despite losing over two legs, and you could argue that they should have to earn it. I.e play a semi-final against another team that hasn't cheated. 

I am aware that's probably convoluted, and a line has to be drawn somewhere. I also understand, and think the argument of 'Saints cheated against Boro, so they effectively lose the tie 3-0 via forfeit' is a reasonable one. 

It's all very messy, isn't it?

Wrexham didn’t make the playoffs over 46 games, why should they suddenly be put in the playoffs because Saints cheated after they’d qualified?

Boro would then have to play 4 games to reach the final, after Hull have only played 2, and Wrexham could reach it through only playing 2, despite Boro being the victims of the cheating?

Saints broke the rules and have been thrown out. As with every other case where a team cheats in a knock out game, the opposition gets a by into the final.

All reasonable and fair points. 

Saints being expelled from the play-offs effectively means all teams are bumped up one place in my mind, so Wrexham would be the 6th team - that's where I was coming from.

And if they’d been kicked out before the playoffs had started, I’d agree, but the cheating charge directly relates to a playoff game, so it has no impact on Wrexham whatsoever.

You could argue they have cheated at other points in the season, and should have been disqualified for that reason, but it needed to be resolved before the playoffs, you can’t punish Boro for being a spied on on by making them play again.
Reply
Its the Saints fans I feel sorry for, especially the ones who run in front of us lording it up in the play offs a couple of years ago. Ah wait - fuck em
Reply
Re the points deduction for next season. Southampton have admitted to breaking the rules in League games this season in addition to the play-off game, so a penalty relating to the League in addition to the play-offs would be justified. So I wouldn't expect the points deduction to be waived. Possibly reduced by one or two points.

Alternately, waived completely and replaced with Southampton being expelled from the Championship, with Oxford then staying up. Which would be ironic, considering that Oxford were one of the teams they'd admitted spying on yet hadn't actually suffered because of it.
Reply
(05-20-2026, 07:10 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: Re the points deduction for next season. Southampton have admitted to breaking the rules in League games this season in addition to the play-off game, so a penalty relating to the League in addition to the play-offs would be justified. So I wouldn't expect the points deduction to be waived. Possibly reduced by one or two points.

Alternately, waived completely and replaced with Southampton being expelled from the Championship, with Oxford then staying up. Which would be ironic, considering that Oxford were one of the teams they'd admitted spying on yet hadn't actually suffered because of it.

I mean it would be fucking hilarious if Southampton were deducted yet more points, or administratively relegated for a frivolous appeal, but it wont happen.

I think at best they'll get the 4 points suspended pending future conduct, and that it's more likely they'll be reduced to 2 points for cooperating and admitting fault. 

They absolutely cannot reinstate them into the final as it's not fair on either set of supporters, or Hull who will have spent today preparing for Boro!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 5 Guest(s)