This season tells me one thing…
#11
The problem with Mason is a lack of bollocks, as a new manager he has a free hit this season, we have a squad that will finish mid table at a canter, but you get the feeling he is already looking over his shoulder even when we were top 6 and that seems to have already infected a team already lacking in leadership on the pitch.
Reply
#12
Exactly Ted our squad isn’t the quality it was even last year.

For others on the thread, you want an inexperienced head coach to play the kids and still get results you deem acceptable, which currently seems to be the play-offs.

Just own the fact you didn’t want him at the club and would have preferred someone else. I made no bones about the fact I didn’t want TM or rate him. At least own your bias, don’t dress it up with excuses.

None of us know how good, bad or average Mason is, I doubt he even knows. It’s hardly helpful when we sit just four points outside the play-off to be waiting impatiently for him to feck up so we can’t start the managerial merry-go-round again.
Reply
#13
I think we have been boring and passive more often than not, but I really enjoyed the second half for a number of reasons. Most of all because the crowd woke up when they scored. It became a little toxic (I wish those fans would sod off and not bother coming to games, that's what Villa fans act like), but thankfully most of that was drowned out by excellent vocal support in the circumstances. 

Whilst I agree it can be and has been boring, yesterday wasn't. For me, anyway. I actually enjoyed the game.

I've probably been a bit harsh there, as I accept fans have a right to be frustrated, it hasn't been great, has it. I get it. But I also can't stand the idea that some fans couldn't wait for Oxford to score so they could vent their poison. Those are probably in the minority, but it was definitely the case. You could sense it every time Oxford dared to attack, or one of our players had the temerity to play a backwards pass. They were waiting and wanting us to lose yesterday. What's the point in that, why bother going to the game? Just stay at home! Huh
Reply
#14
(11-09-2025, 09:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Exactly Ted our squad isn’t the quality it was even last year.

For others on the thread, you want an inexperienced head coach to play the kids and still get results you deem acceptable, which currently seems to be the play-offs.

Just own the fact you didn’t want him at the club and would have preferred someone else. I made no bones about the fact I didn’t want TM or rate him. At least own your bias, don’t dress it up with excuses.

None of us know how good, bad or average Mason is, I doubt he even knows. It’s hardly helpful when we sit just four points outside the play-off to be waiting impatiently for him to feck up so we can’t start the managerial merry-go-round again.

Don't get me wrong, I still agree with decent chunks of what SW and Lurker are saying about the coaching and the setup but given the resources he's been given it feels unfair to lay all the blame for this season's performance at his door.
Reply
#15
(11-09-2025, 09:20 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 09:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Exactly Ted our squad isn’t the quality it was even last year.

For others on the thread, you want an inexperienced head coach to play the kids and still get results you deem acceptable, which currently seems to be the play-offs.

Just own the fact you didn’t want him at the club and would have preferred someone else. I made no bones about the fact I didn’t want TM or rate him. At least own your bias, don’t dress it up with excuses.

None of us know how good, bad or average Mason is, I doubt he even knows. It’s hardly helpful when we sit just four points outside the play-off to be waiting impatiently for him to feck up so we can’t start the managerial merry-go-round again.

Don't get me wrong, I still agree with decent chunks of what SW and Lurker are saying about the coaching and the setup but given the resources he's been given it feels unfair to lay all the blame for this season's performance at his door.

I agree some matches have been boring, but tbh some matches under Val, CC were snorefests to watch too. I’m leaving Bruce and TM out as they were awful appointments.
Reply
#16
Lads, football in general has become boring. It's not an us issue. It's how the game has gone! Identikit tactics and styles, and most teams have possession for the sake of it. It's rubbish, to be frank.
Reply
#17
(11-09-2025, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: … and that is, fans talk a good game about building squads over several seasons, with young ambitious players and giving head coaches an opportunity to build sides over two or three years. The reality is those that advocate this approach the most, are the quickest to want the head coach sacked when they don’t get instant success, and that in our case is being in the play-off positions all season it seems. Despite the fact if they had a manager (sexy foreign name perhaps) they wanted ‘consolidation’ in midtable would be fine. 

Every sentence uttered by the head coach is ripped to shreds, every sub is declared awful, every defeat is appalling, every victory is due to how poor the opponents are. I even get the feeling after yesterday’s result some are very disappointed we won just so their wish for a new manager would become a step closer. 

Did anyone really think this season regardless of the balance of the squad, or mistakes by a rookie head coach would see us do anything but us bobble along where we are now? Fans either want a ‘project’ or they don’t. They either want to show patience in the rebuilding process or they don’t, they either accept our overspending in the past is causing us to readjust to being one of ten clubs who could finish anywhere from 14th-5th depending upon injuries etc or they don’t. 

The reactions on here and at the ground suggest that what fans really want is a team never out the play-off positions, playing exciting football, scoring lots of goals and led by a manager who is charismatic, almost the finished product, and well someone they said we should have appointed/have lost instead.

Everything in this post is bang on...

except I'm someone who would advocate building a squad over time, developing talent with an eye to a profit, re invested in the squad. But I am not in favour of changing the manager. He needs more time, at least half a season and only change this season if relegation becomes a real possibility. 

The championship is a slog and sadly the football is often turgid.. teams are more adept at spoiling than creating.

And in many ways if squad development is your aim, being better in the second half of the season is preferable to being best in the first half.
Reply
#18
(11-09-2025, 09:28 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Lads, football in general has become boring. It's not an us issue. It's how the game has gone! Identikit tactics and styles, and most teams have possession for the sake of it. It's rubbish, to be frank.

It's not an unreasonable observation but it's certainly not how we set up under Carlos, Mowbray I'm not sure what or if there was a plan and the jury remains out on Mason.
Reply
#19
(11-09-2025, 09:28 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Lads, football in general has become boring. It's not an us issue. It's how the game has gone! Identikit tactics and styles, and most teams have possession for the sake of it. It's rubbish, to be frank.

Agreed, the trouble is, we dress football up as some pseudoscience, (you know who you are) and yet almost every team in reality just copied Pep ball for the last decade. No innovation, no managing to a squads strength just tedious ‘I read in a PDF manual and at my coaching course’ identikit and formulaic tactics. Teams in the Prem are now playing more direct again, watch the Championship and St Augustine’s CoE under 10s play similar in the next five years. 

Football used to be a game where one week you played a direct team, then the next a tippy happy team, now managers tactics are like algorithmic straitjackets boring the shit out of fans up and down the country. This is hardly a stick to beat Mason with.

(11-09-2025, 09:35 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 09:28 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Lads, football in general has become boring. It's not an us issue. It's how the game has gone! Identikit tactics and styles, and most teams have possession for the sake of it. It's rubbish, to be frank.

It's not an unreasonable observation but it's certainly not how we set up under Carlos, Mowbray I'm not sure what or if there was a plan and the jury remains out on Mason.

Whoah, CC played mind numbingly boring football at times with better players, twenty passes in our own half between defender and goalkeeper, only for us to draw the game 1-1. That’s not really a criticism of him more a criticism of Pep ball tactics employed by most coaches.
Reply
#20
(11-09-2025, 09:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Exactly Ted our squad isn’t the quality it was even last year.

For others on the thread, you want an inexperienced head coach to play the kids and still get results you deem acceptable, which currently seems to be the play-offs.

Just own the fact you didn’t want him at the club and would have preferred someone else. I made no bones about the fact I didn’t want TM or rate him. At least own your bias, don’t dress it up with excuses.

None of us know how good, bad or average Mason is, I doubt he even knows. It’s hardly helpful when we sit just four points outside the play-off to be waiting impatiently for him to feck up so we can’t start the managerial merry-go-round again.

I have to hold my hands up and say, so far, I got it wrong. 

I was intrigued by Masons experience and back story. I expected having such a close relationship with Poch, and learned from Jose and Conte he would have a lot to offer. Alas, he hasn't. 

I was wrong, and he is carp.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: