Team for Charlton
#31
(11-04-2025, 09:06 AM)Merkinagogo Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 08:29 AM)Peachofacross Wrote: I'd shake it up a bit. 3-5-2 of sorts. I think people have forgotten how good Campbell looked at centre half at the start of the season and his pace and ball carrying at the back would be handy in a three.

I'd give MJ a free role off Maja and tell him to do what the fuck he wants as we have no other creativity. Price should be given a go alongside Mowatt in an 8 role and having Campbell at the centre of a back 3 would afford him that protection to go forwards.

I was very tempted to put SIJ at lwb as he played there for borough but I'd probably stick with Styles for the first try out of the formation.

------------Griffiths------------
----Phillips----Campbell------Mepham
Alfie------Price------Mowatt---------Styles
--------------MJ----------------------
--------------------Maja------------------

Or we could try 11 players..  Big Grin

Probably figured this is the same as picking Grant or SIJ.
Reply
#32
(11-04-2025, 09:09 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 09:06 AM)Merkinagogo Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 08:29 AM)Peachofacross Wrote: I'd shake it up a bit. 3-5-2 of sorts. I think people have forgotten how good Campbell looked at centre half at the start of the season and his pace and ball carrying at the back would be handy in a three.

I'd give MJ a free role off Maja and tell him to do what the fuck he wants as we have no other creativity. Price should be given a go alongside Mowatt in an 8 role and having Campbell at the centre of a back 3 would afford him that protection to go forwards.

I was very tempted to put SIJ at lwb as he played there for borough but I'd probably stick with Styles for the first try out of the formation.

------------Griffiths------------
----Phillips----Campbell------Mepham
Alfie------Price------Mowatt---------Styles
--------------MJ----------------------
--------------------Maja------------------

Or we could try 11 players..  Big Grin

Probably figured this is the same as picking Grant or SIJ.

Fair comment..
Reply
#33
(11-04-2025, 09:10 AM)Merkinagogo Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 09:09 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 09:06 AM)Merkinagogo Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 08:29 AM)Peachofacross Wrote: I'd shake it up a bit. 3-5-2 of sorts. I think people have forgotten how good Campbell looked at centre half at the start of the season and his pace and ball carrying at the back would be handy in a three.

I'd give MJ a free role off Maja and tell him to do what the fuck he wants as we have no other creativity. Price should be given a go alongside Mowatt in an 8 role and having Campbell at the centre of a back 3 would afford him that protection to go forwards.

I was very tempted to put SIJ at lwb as he played there for borough but I'd probably stick with Styles for the first try out of the formation.

------------Griffiths------------
----Phillips----Campbell------Mepham
Alfie------Price------Mowatt---------Styles
--------------MJ----------------------
--------------------Maja------------------

Or we could try 11 players..  Big Grin

Probably figured this is the same as picking Grant or SIJ.

Fair comment..
Might get a draw with 12, 10, no chance!  Big Grin
Reply
#34
(11-04-2025, 09:09 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 09:06 AM)Merkinagogo Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 08:29 AM)Peachofacross Wrote: I'd shake it up a bit. 3-5-2 of sorts. I think people have forgotten how good Campbell looked at centre half at the start of the season and his pace and ball carrying at the back would be handy in a three.

I'd give MJ a free role off Maja and tell him to do what the fuck he wants as we have no other creativity. Price should be given a go alongside Mowatt in an 8 role and having Campbell at the centre of a back 3 would afford him that protection to go forwards.

I was very tempted to put SIJ at lwb as he played there for borough but I'd probably stick with Styles for the first try out of the formation.

------------Griffiths------------
----Phillips----Campbell------Mepham
Alfie------Price------Mowatt---------Styles
--------------MJ----------------------
--------------------Maja------------------

Or we could try 11 players..  Big Grin

Probably figured this is the same as picking Grant or SIJ.

That was exactly what I thought....?

Stick Dike up with Maja.
Reply
#35
Ultimately we can pick whatever formation we want - the change Mason has to make is to get another attacking player into his XI - be that Price dropping deeper and adding Maja as a 10 with Heggebo or Dike, or it's finding a way to get Bany into the 11.

I'm a huge fan of a back 3, but not if it means Styles and Gilchrist are the wingbacks, as that will just be putting another defensive minded player into the XI - if we move to a back 3 we have to have SIJ or Grant in at LWB and keep Mikey further forward where he can be supported by that player. Even using Gilchrist on the other side would be a defensive move given his lack of ball carrying ability of pace.

Not one for Charlton tonight but against Oxford (and possibly last weekend against Weds) was a game for Price at RWB just to get another body in there.

Griffiths

Campbell
Phillips
Mepham

Grant
Mowatt
Diakite
Price

Bany
Johnston

Dike

We'll fugging shit 'em!
Reply
#36
(11-04-2025, 11:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Ultimately we can pick whatever formation we want - the change Mason has to make is to get another attacking player into his XI - be that Price dropping deeper and adding Maja as a 10 with Heggebo or Dike, or it's finding a way to get Bany into the 11.

I'm a huge fan of a back 3, but not if it means Styles and Gilchrist are the wingbacks, as that will just be putting another defensive minded player into the XI - if we move to a back 3 we have to have SIJ or Grant in at LWB and keep Mikey further forward where he can be supported by that player. Even using Gilchrist on the other side would be a defensive move given his lack of ball carrying ability of pace.

Not one for Charlton tonight but against Oxford (and possibly last weekend against Weds) was a game for Price at RWB just to get another body in there.

Griffiths

Campbell
Phillips
Mepham

Grant
Mowatt
Diakite
Price

Bany
Johnston

Dike

We'll fugging shit 'em!

This is horrible, right to left on defence, left to right on midfield. Do better.  Big Grin
Reply
#37
Campbell is out injured isn't he?
Reply
#38
I confidently predict the starting lineup will be the same as Saturday’s. It’s the classic definition of madness, doing the same thing over & over again and expecting a different outcome.

I’ll hold my hand up if I’m wrong, but really does anyone think he will have devised a different plan since Saturday?
Reply
#39
(11-04-2025, 01:46 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: I confidently predict the starting lineup will be the same as Saturday’s. It’s the classic definition of madness, doing the same thing over & over again and expecting a different outcome.

I’ll hold my hand up if I’m wrong, but really does anyone think he will have devised a different plan since Saturday?

SIJ will not play unless he's becoming Mason’s Button.
Reply
#40
When we sold Fellows, Wallace became our only genuine RW, so if we play a back 4 he has to start, if fit. And no, I can't believe I'm saying it either.
SIJ deserves a chance on the left, but not at MJ's expense, so he has to make way unless we drop Price and play MJ more central.
We really are at sixes and sevens when it almost makes sense to drop Price and play Wallace.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)