Difficult to know what happens next with Mason
#1
Mason hasn't had a full strength squad at any point this season. Today he was missing Collyer, Molumby, Campbell and Wallace - but all of those except Collyer are regularly criticized on here. So arguably no great loss.

All his attacking resources (except Jed) were in the starting XI or on the bench. So why leave it so late to make changes?

You get five subs - so why change both full backs? They weren't on yellow cards, they didn't seem to be struggling. Surely he could have made more attacking changes?

I see the opinion that "Mason needs two transfer windows to get things right". But who's choosing the transfer targets? Not Mason, that's for sure. Can we be sure he'll do better with different players not chosen by him?

What I see is a coach who doesn't seem to motivate his squad and whose tactics don't stretch as far as creating goal chances. Sacking him makes us look like a club in disarray, but what's the alternative? Does the "President and Sporting Director" have a little chat with him about effective coaching and realistic expectations of results? That always goes down like a lead balloon with football professionals. Does anyone else on the coaching staff have the confidence and authority to suggest a change in approach? Because we've seen the same toothless plan and below-par performance match after match.

I can't see a positive outcome to this situation. It would seem wrong to sack Mason too soon and foolish to sack him too late. I wish I could see a glimmer of light at the end of the tunnel.
Reply
#2
This is 2 bad coaching appointments in a row.

3rd time lucky?

I don't have the faith.

I feel for RM. He was offered an opportunity, took it, but wasn't up to the challenge.
He'll find his niche somewhere else.

Nestor however has to go. 

Shilen has to take charge now.
Reply
#3
(11-01-2025, 05:33 PM)Albionmad Wrote: This is 2 bad coaching appointments in a row.

3rd time lucky?

I don't have the faith.

I feel for RM. He was offered an opportunity, took it, but wasn't up to the challenge.
He'll find his niche somewhere else.

Nestor however has to go. 

Shilan has to take charge now.

Isn't Nestor Patel's 'man' though?
Reply
#4
(11-01-2025, 05:34 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:
(11-01-2025, 05:33 PM)Albionmad Wrote: This is 2 bad coaching appointments in a row.

3rd time lucky?

I don't have the faith.

I feel for RM. He was offered an opportunity, took it, but wasn't up to the challenge.
He'll find his niche somewhere else.

Nestor however has to go. 

Shilan has to take charge now.

Isn't Nestor Patel's 'man' though?

Well divorce is still legal
Reply
#5
(11-01-2025, 05:21 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Mason hasn't had a full strength squad at any point this season. Today he was missing Collyer, Molumby, Campbell and Wallace - but all of those except Collyer are regularly criticized on here. So arguably no great loss.

All his attacking resources (except Jed) were in the starting XI or on the bench. So why leave it so late to make changes?

You get five subs - so why change both full backs? They weren't on yellow cards, they didn't seem to be struggling. Surely he could have made more attacking changes?

I see the opinion that "Mason needs two transfer windows to get things right". But who's choosing the transfer targets? Not Mason, that's for sure. Can we be sure he'll do better with different players not chosen by him?

What I see is a coach who doesn't seem to motivate his squad and whose tactics don't stretch as far as creating goal chances. Sacking him makes us look like a club in disarray, but what's the alternative? Does the "President and Sporting Director" have a little chat with him about effective coaching and realistic expectations of results? That always goes down like a lead balloon with football professionals. Does anyone else on the coaching staff have the confidence and authority to suggest a change in approach? Because we've seen the same toothless plan and below-par performance match after match.

I can't see a positive outcome to this situation. It would seem wrong to sack Mason too soon and foolish to sack him too late. I wish I could see a glimmer of light at the end of the tunnel.

During a sad visit to the vets a few years ago, the Vet said to me "It's better to put them to sleep 10 days too early than one day late".

The analogy fits here. Change it now.
Reply
#6
This is the first true bad appointment. ToMo was a last minute, convenient, and logical stop gap after Wicky fucked up his backroom staff. All after CC left on short notice mid season.

However, the pressure is definitely on for the next appt if Mason doesn't sort his shit out.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#7
I can sympathise with Nestor, TM was well known to be second choice and few saw it working as badly as it did. RM, was a gamble, but he could have been the next Eddie Howe. Hindsight is now showing it’s unlikely to be the case. He does however have to make a solid appointment with RM’s successor. There aren’t exactly a wealth of good options, nor were there previously which led to the gamble on RM.

FWIW, I don’t think Rohl would have come, he would have wanted bigger and better.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#8
(11-01-2025, 05:39 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: I can sympathise with Nestor, TM was well known to be second choice and few saw it working as badly as it did. RM, was a gamble, but he could have been the next Eddie Howe. Hindsight is now showing it’s unlikely to be the case. He does however have to make a solid appointment with RM’s successor. There aren’t exactly a wealth of good options, nor were there previously which led to the gamble on RM.

FWIW, I don’t think Rohl would have come, he would have wanted bigger and better.
What was there to suggest that though Midge? In fairness I wanted Cifuentes and that now looks like a bullet dodged but Mason had nothing to suggest he would be any good. It was a stupid risky punt that we didn’t need to make.
Reply
#9
(11-01-2025, 05:39 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: I can sympathise with Nestor, TM was well known to be second choice and few saw it working as badly as it did. RM, was a gamble, but he could have been the next Eddie Howe. Hindsight is now showing it’s unlikely to be the case. He does however have to make a solid appointment with RM’s successor. There aren’t exactly a wealth of good options, nor were there previously which led to the gamble on RM.

FWIW, I don’t think Rohl would have come, he would have wanted bigger and better.

The absolute last thing we needed when he came in was TM. That was utterly ridiculous
Reply
#10
(11-01-2025, 05:39 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: I can sympathise with Nestor, TM was well known to be second choice and few saw it working as badly as it did. RM, was a gamble, but he could have been the next Eddie Howe. Hindsight is now showing it’s unlikely to be the case. He does however have to make a solid appointment with RM’s successor. There aren’t exactly a wealth of good options, nor were there previously which led to the gamble on RM.

FWIW, I don’t think Rohl would have come, he would have wanted bigger and better.

Given where he ended up I’m not convinced that’s the case.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)